Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence


Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence > Year 2004 > July 2004 Decisions > Sayson v. Luna : AM P-04-1829 : July 7, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Resolution:




Sayson v. Luna : AM P-04-1829 : July 7, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Resolution

PHILIPPINE SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

SECOND DIVISION

[A.M. NO. P-04-1829 : July 7, 2004]

GLORIA R. SAYSON, FRANCISCO R. RELLOROSA, RUSTICO Y. CAPARAS, Complainants, v. EFREN LUNA, Sheriff III, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 37, Quezon City, Respondent.

R E S O L U T I O N

CALLEJO, SR., J.:

The instant administrative case arose from the Affidavit-Complaint1 dated August 4, 1999 of Gloria R. Sayson, Francisco R. Rellorosa and Rustico Y. Caparas charging Efren Luna, Sheriff III, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 37, Quezon City, with grave misconduct and/or conduct prejudicial to the best interests of the service relative to Civil Case No. 37-15744, entitled Genaro Serrano v. Gregorio Rellorosa.

The complainants alleged that the weekend before July 15, 1999, Gregorio Rellorosa informed them that his car would be levied upon pursuant to a writ of execution issued by the Metropolitan Trial Court of Quezon City, and that it was scheduled to be sold at public auction at 10:00 a.m. on July 15, 1999. Rellorosa requested them to participate in the bidding, to which they agreed, subject to the condition that in case one of them would win the bid, they would allow Rellorosa to redeem the car within one year at the bid price plus accrued interest.

The complainants alleged that at 9:00 a.m. of July 15, 1999, they met Rellorosa and agreed to pool their resources so that they would come out as the highest bidder. They also met the respondent sheriff that same morning.Upon being told that the scheduled auction sale had been postponed to July 19, 1999, the complainants left. They, however, later learned from Rellorosa that the respondent sheriff conducted the auction sale of the said car at 2:00 p.m. that same day.

In his comment, the respondent narrated that he levied the car in question pursuant to a writ of execution2 issued by the court.The auction sale was set at 10:00 a.m. of July 15, 1999, with due notice to Gregorio Rellorosa.Three days prior to the scheduled auction sale or on July 12, 1999, Gregorio Rellorosa filed a Petition for Relief from Judgment with Urgent Prayer for Preliminary Injunction Inter Alia and Temporary Restraining Order to Stop Sheriffs Sale Scheduled on July 15, 1999.3 The respondent further averred that he came to see Gregorio Rellorosa alone in the morning of July 15, 1999, and informed the latter that his motion was denied.He also told Gregorio that the auction sale would not push through as scheduled, but would proceed any time of the day once the order was signed.

The respondent avers that he advised Gregorio to wait for the plaintiff, Genaro Serrano, to ask if the latter would postpone the auction sale, but Rellorosa immediately left.

The instant case was then referred to Second Vice-Executive Judge Thelma A. Ponferrada, Regional Trial Court, Branch 104, Quezon City.After conducting an investigation on the matter, the Executive Judge recommended the exoneration of the respondent, and opined that the latter was able to substantially comply with the requirements for the conduct of a public auction.

We agree.

The respondent sheriff acted in accordance with the Writ of Execution4 dated June 11, 1999, as issued by Judge Augustus C. Diaz, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 37, Quezon City. Indeed, a sheriffs duty
in the execution of a writ is purely ministerial he is to execute the order of the court strictly to the letter, and he has no discretion whether to execute the judgment or not.5 A perusal of the notice of levy and sale will also show that the sale at public auction was to take place on July 15, 1999 at 10:00 a.m. or soon thereafter at the front of [the] Hall of Justice Building, Q.C.6 As found by Executive Judge Ponferrada, such notice was served on July 8, 1999, or more than five (5) days before the scheduled auction sale. Furthermore, a sheriffs report, in this case the Minutes of the Auction Sale,7 as a document, is clothed with the presumption of regularity, and since it was not objected to by the complainant, it must be upheld.8 cralawred

The complainants failed to substantiate the charges against the respondent. As against the bare allegations of misconduct with no cogent proof thereon, and the presumption of regularity in the performance of official functions, the latter shall prevail.

WHEREFORE, the Court resolves to DISMISS the complaint against respondent Efren Luna, Sheriff III, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 37, Quezon City, for lack of merit.

SO ORDERED.

Puno, (Chairman), Quisumbing, Austria-Martinez, and TINGA, JJ., concur.

Endnotes:


1 Rollo, pp. 12-13.

The instant complaint was initially addressed to the Office of the Ombudsman and docketed as OMB-0-99-1612 for misrepresentation and deceit. In an Order dated August 24, 1999, the said complaint was dismissed for lack of merit, and was referred to the Court.

2 Annexes 1-C,1-D, Rollo, pp. 93-94.

3 Exhibit 1, Rollo, p. 90.

4 Supra at note 2.

5 Garcia v. Yared, 399 SCRA 331 (2003).

6 Exhibit 6, Rollo, p. 66.

7 Exhibit 3-R, Id. at 115.

8 See Sy v. Yerro , 253 SCRA 340 (1996).




Back to Home | Back to Main




















chanrobles.com





ChanRobles On-Line Bar Review

ChanRobles Internet Bar Review : www.chanroblesbar.com

ChanRobles MCLE On-line

ChanRobles Lawnet Inc. - ChanRobles MCLE On-line : www.chanroblesmcleonline.com






July-2004 Jurisprudence                 

  • Nordic Asia Ltd v. CA: 111159 : July 13, 2004 : J. Azcuna : Special First Division : Decision

  • Uy v. Sandiganbayan : 111544 : July 6, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Carlos A Gothong Lines Inc v. CA: 113576 : July 1, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Foster-Gallego v. Sps Galang : 130228 : July 27, 2004 : J. Carpio : First Division : Decision

  • Velasco v. CA: 130244 : July 7, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Decision

  • Zarate v. The Dir of Lands : 131501 : July 14, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • People v. Alzona : 132029 : July 30, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Decision

  • Narte v. CA: 132552 : July 14, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Decision

  • People v. Tomaquin : 133188 : July 23, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Decision

  • People v. Murillo : 134583 : July 14, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : En Banc : Decision

  • Towne & City Dev't Corp v. CA: 135043 : July 14, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Decision

  • Tambunting v. CA: 135786 : July 23, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Decision

  • Rayos v. CA: 135528 : July 14, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Eastern Telecoms v. Int'l Communication Corp : 135992 : July 23, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Decision

  • Alon v. CA: 136422 : July 7, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Plaza II v. Cassion : 136809 : July 27, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : Third Division : Decision

  • Villamor v. CA: 136858 : July 21, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Lazaro v. Social Security : 138254 : July 30, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Decision

  • People v. Abatayo : 139456 : July 7, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • National Onion Growers Coop Mktg Assn v. Lo : 141493 : July 28, 2004 : J. Carpio : First Division : Decision

  • Phil Export & Foreign Loan Guarantee Corp v. V.P. Eusebio Construction : 140047 : July 13, 2004 : C.J. Davide Jr : First Division : Decision

  • Tan v. Timbal Jr : 141926 : July 14, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Beroa v. Sandiganbayan : 142456 : July 27, 2004 : J. Carpio : First Division : Decision

  • Landbank v. Sps Banal : 143276 : July 20, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : Third Division : Decision

  • Inding v. Sandiganbayan : 143047 : July 14, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : En Banc : Decision

  • Special Steel Products Inc v. Villereal : 143304 : July 8, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : Third Division : Decision

  • Viking Industrial Corporation v. CA: 143794 : July 13, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : Third Division : Decision

  • Saint Louis University v. Cordero : 144118 : July 21, 2004 : C.J. Davide Jr : First Division : Decision

  • Globe v. NTC : 143964 : July 26, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Decision

  • Tomacruz-Lactao v. Espejo : 144410 : July 21, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Decision

  • People v. Parreno : 144343 : July 7, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Mercury Drug Corp v. Libunao : 144458 : July 14, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Trans-Asia Shipping Lines v. CA: 145428 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • People v. Tan : 144707 : July 13, 2004 : J. Azcuna : En Banc : Decision

  • Zamboanga Barter Goods Retailers Assn v. Lobregat : 145466 : July 7, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Quelan v. VHF Phils Inc : 145911 : July 7, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : En Banc : Decision

  • Custodio v. Corrado : 146082 : July 30, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : First Division : Decision

  • Rufina Patis Factory v. Alusitain : 146202 : July 14, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Decision

  • Phil Ports Authority v. Sargasso Construction & Dev't Corp : 146478 : July 30, 2004 : J. Tinga : En Banc : Separate Opinion

  • Phil Ports Authority v. 146478 : July 30, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : En Banc : Decision

  • Toralba v. Mercado : 146480 : July 14, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : Second Division : Decision

  • GSIS Cebu Br v. Montesclaros : 146494 : July 14, 2004 : J. Carpio : En Banc : Decision

  • Miranda v. Besa : 146513 : July 30, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Heirs of Restrivera v. De Guzman : 146540 : July 14, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : Third Division : Decision

  • Valiao v. CA: 146621 : July 30, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : First Division : Decision

  • Francisco v. People : 146584 : July 12, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Divison : Decision

  • Guiang v. Co : 146996 : July 30, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Divsion : Decision

  • Electruck Asia Inc v. Meris : 147031 : July 27, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Decision

  • Rural Bank of Sta Catalina v. Land Bank of the Phils : 148019 : July 26, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Reyno v. Manila Elec Co : 148105 : July 22, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : Third Division : Decision

  • Lopez v. CA: 148510 : July 21, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Resolution

  • Pahang v. Vestil : 148595 : July 12, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • People v. Pendatun : 148822 : July 12, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Pangilinan v. Gen Milling Corp : 149329 : July 12, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Torres v. Specialized Packaging Dev't Corp : 149634 : July 6, 2004 : J. Panganiban : First Division : Decision

  • People v. Chua : 149538 : Juky 26, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Maturan v. People : 150353-54 : July 27, 2004 : J. Quiusmbing : First Division : Decision

  • Filcon Manufacturing Corp v. Lakas Manggagawa sa Filcon : 150166 : July 26, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Rural Bank of Makati Inc v. Municipality of Makati : 150763 : July 2, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : Second Division : Decision

  • Contex Corp v. CIR : 151135 : July 2, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : Second Division : Decision

  • Romera v. People : 151978 : July 14, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : Second Division : Decision

  • DHL Phils Corp v. Buklod ng Manggagawa ng DHL Phils Corp : 152094 : July 22, 2004 : J. Panganiban : THird Division : Decision

  • Romualdez v. Sandiganbayan : 152259 : July 29, 2004 : J. Tinga : En Banc : Separate Opinion

  • Romualdez v. Sandiganbayan : 152259 : July 29, 2004 : J. Panganiban : En Banc : Decision

  • Salvatierra v. Monfort III : 152542 : July 8, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Reyes-De Leon v. Del Rosario : 152862 : July 26, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Decision

  • East Asia Traders Inc v. Rep of the Phils : 152947 : July 7, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : Third Division : Decision

  • Dwikarna v. Domingo : 153454 : July 7, 2004 : J. Corona : En Banc : Decision

  • Calingin v. CA: 154616 : July 12, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : Second Division : Resolution

  • Joaquino v. Reyes : 154645 : July 13, 2004 : J. Panganiban : First Division : Decision

  • People v. Medina : 155256 : July 30, 2004 : C.J. Davide : First Division : Decision

  • Mendoza v. Rural Bank of Lucban : 155421 : July 7, 2004 : J. Panganiban : First Division : Decision

  • Marifosque v. People : 156685 : July 27, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Ngo v. People : 155815 : July 14, 2004 : J. Panganiban : First Division : Decision

  • Pentagon Int'l Shipping v. Adelantar : 157373 : July 27, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • People v. Casolocan : 156890 : July 13, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Decision

  • Cabugao v. People : 158033 : July 30, 2004 : J. Puno : Second Division : Decision

  • Simangan v. People : 157984 : July 8, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Manila Water Co Inc v. Pena : 158255 : July 8, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Punzalan v. Pea : 158543 : July 21, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Querubin v. The Regional Cluster Director : 159299 : July 7, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : En Banc : Decision

  • European Resources & Technologies v. Nolte : 159586 : July 26, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Landl & Co v. Metrobank : 159622 : July 30, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Sps David v. Sps Quiambao : 159795 : July 30, 2004 : J. Puno : Second Division : Decision

  • Samson v. Daway : 160054-55 : July 21, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Sps Hernandez v. Sps Dolor : 160286 : July 30, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Batabor v. COMELEC : 160428 : July 21, 2004 : J. Sandoval-Gutierrez : En Banc : Decision

  • Sps Vera Cruz v. Calderon : 160748 : July 14, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : First Division : Decision

  • Gatchalian v. CA: 161645 : July 30, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Resolution

  • Celino v. Heirs of Santiago : 161817 : July 30, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Resolution

  • Albaa v. Comelec : 163302 : July 23, 2004 : J. Callejo, Sr : En Banc : Decision

  • Gonzaga v. Villanueva Jr : AC 1954 : July 23, 2004 : C.J. Davide Jr : First Division : Resolution

  • Roncal v. Paray : AC 3882 : July 30, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Decision

  • Cuizon v. Macalino : AC 4334 : July 7, 2004 : Per Curiam : En Banc : Decison

  • Serzo v. Atty Flores : AC 6040 : July 30, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Decision

  • Cambaliza v. Cristal-Tenorio : AC 6290 : July 14, 2004 : J. Davide Jr : First Division : Resolution

  • Parias v. Paguinto : AC 6297 : July 13, 2004 : J. Carpio : First Division : Decision

  • Initial Report on the Financial Audit conducted in the MTC of Pulilan Bulacan : AM 01-11-291-MTC : July 7, 2004 : Per Curiam : En Banc : Resolution

  • Report on the Judicial Audit in the RTC, Br 71, Antipolo City : AM 03-11-652-RTC : July 21, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Re: Compliance of Judge Rosete : July 29, 2004 : AM 04-5-118-MTCC : C.J. Davide Jr : En Banc : Resolution

  • Oktubre v. Velasco : AM MTJ-02-1444 : July 22, 2004 : Per Curiam : En Banc : Decision

  • Almojuela Jr v. Ringor : AM MTJ-04-1521 : July 27, 2004 : J. Ynares-Santiago : En Banc : Decision

  • Re: Complaint of Atty Claveria : AM P-02-1626 : July 7, 2004 : Per Curiam : En Banc : Resolution

  • Gonzalo v. Mejia : AM P-02-1662 : July 28, 2004 : Per Curiam : En Banc : Decision

  • Inting v. Borja : AM P-03-1707 : July 27, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Decision

  • OCAD v. Juan : AM P-03-1726 : July 22, 2004 : Per Curiam : En Banc : Decision

  • Prak v. Anacan : AM P-03-1738 : July 12, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Resolution

  • Aonuevo v. Rubio : AM P-04-1782 : July 30, 2004 : J. Puno : Second Division : Resolution

  • Monserate v. Adolfo : AM P-04-1823 : July 12, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Sayson v. Luna : AM P-04-1829 : July 7, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Resolution

  • Gamboa v. Gamboa : AM P-04-1836 : July 30, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Resolution

  • Ratti v. De Castro : AM P 04-1844 : July 23, 2004 : Per Curiam : En Banc : Decision

  • Imperial v. Basilla : AM P-04-1852 : July 30, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Resolution

  • Veloso v. Caminade : AM RTJ-01-1655 : July 8, 2004 : J. Corona : Third Division : Resolution

  • Pantig v. Daing Jr : AM RTJ-03-1791 : July 8, 2004 : J. Corona : Third Division : Resolution

  • Sevilla v. Borreta : AM RTJ-04-1836 : July 14, 2004 : J. Quisumbing : Second Division

  • Sierra v. Tiamson : AM RTJ-04-1847 : July 21, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Resolution

  • Mupas v. Espaol : AM RTJ-04-1850 : July 14, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Resolution

  • Dialo Jr v. Macias : AM RTJ 04-1859 : July 13, 2004 : J. Carpio-Morales : Third Division : Decision

  • Corpus v. Ochotorena : AM RTJ-04-1861 : July 30, 2004 : J. Tinga : Second Division : Decision

  • Cepeda v. Cloribel-Purugganan : AM RTJ-04-1866 : July 30, 2004 : J. Callejo Sr : Second Division : Decision

  • Rivera v. Mirasol : AM RTJ-04-1885 : July 14, 2004 : J. Austria-Martinez : Second Division : Resolution

  • Re : Suspension of Atty Maquera from practice of Law : BM 793 : July 30, 2004 : J. Tinga : En Banc : Resolution