ChanRobles Virtual law Library




SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

google search for chanrobles.comSearch for www.chanrobles.com

PLEASE CLICK HERE FOR THE LATEST ➔ SUPREME COURT DECISIONS







August 2005 – PHILIPPINE SUPREME COURT DECISIONS



A.C. No. 6632 : August 2, 2005
Northwestern University, Inc., Et Al. vs. Atty. Macario D. Arquillo.

Decision

J . Panganiban


A.C. No. 4921 : August 3, 2005
Carmelita I. Zaguirre vs. Atty. Alfredo Castillo.

Dissenting Opinion

J. Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 158540 : August 3, 2005
Southern Cross Cement Corp., Vs. Cement Manufacturers Association of the Philippines, Et Al.

Resolution

J . Tinga

Separate Opinion

J. Panganiban


G.R. No. 167147 : August 3, 2005

People of the Philippines vs. Genaro Cayabyab y Fernandez.


A.C. No. 6504 : August 9, 2005
George C. Solatan vs. Attys. Oscar A. Inocentes, Et Al.


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1598 : August 9, 2005
Leonora Bitoon, Et Al. vs. Judge Lorinda B. Toledo-Mupas.

Resolution

J . Quisumbing


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1600 : August 9, 2005
Susana Joaquin Vda. De Agregado vs. Judge Edgardo B. Bellosillo, Et Al.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


A.M. No. P-04-1871 : August 9, 2005
Jose P. Marata vs. Jocelyn C. Fernandez.

Resolution

J . Austria-Martinez


A.M. No. P-04-1879 : August 9, 2005
Leticia Gonzales vs. Romeo S. Gatcheco, Jr., Et Al.

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. P-04-1894 : August 9, 2005
RE: Report on the Financial Audit on the Books of Accounts of Ms. Adelina R. Garrovillas, Et Al.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


A.M. No. RTJ-05-1943 : August 9, 2005
Remigia Sangil Vda. De Dizon, Et Al. vs. Judge Salvador S. Tensuan, Et Al.

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 121920 : August 9, 2005
Municipality of San Juan, Metro Manila vs. The Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 127920 : August 9, 2005
Emilio B. Pacioles, Jr., Et Al. vs. Miguela Chuatoco-Ching.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 133079 : August 9, 2005
Sps . Maximo Landrito, Jr., Et Al. vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 142913 : August 9, 2005
Estate of Salvador Serra Serra, Et Al. vs. Heirs of Primitivo Hernaez, Et Al.

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 144638 : August 9, 2005
Matagumpay Maritime Co., Inc., Et Al. vs. Benedict C. Dela Cruz.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 146823 : August 9, 2005
Spouses Ramon and Estrella Ragudo vs. Fabella Estate Tennants Association, Inc.

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 147756 : August 9, 2005
Roberto O. Ariola, Et Al. vs. Philex Mining Corporation, Et Al.

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 149052 : August 9, 2005
Vibram Manufacturing Corporation vs. Manila Electric Company.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 149111 : August 9, 2005
Jose S. Baltazar vs. Domingo B. Pantig, Et Al.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 149613 : August 9, 2005
Pamela Chan vs. Sandiganbayan.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 150154 : August 9, 2005
Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Toshiba Information Equipment (Phils.), Inc.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 152230 : August 9, 2005
Jesus is Lord Christian School Foundation, Inc. vs. Municipality of Pasig, Metro Manila.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 152427 : August 9, 2005
Integrated Contractor and Plumbing Works, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al.

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 155620 : August 9, 2005
Prudencio Quimbo vs. Acting Ombudsman Margarito Gervacio, Et Al.

Decision

Carpio -Morales


G.R. No. 155738 : August 9, 2005
Angel Pagtalunan vs. Ricardo Manlapig, Et Al.

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 156273 : August 9, 2005
Heirs of Timoteo Moreno, Et Al. vs. Mactan-Cebu International Airport Authority.

Resolution

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 157279 : August 9, 2005
Philippine National Bank vs. Giovanni Palma, Et Al.

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 157611 : August 9, 2005
Alabang Country Club Inc., Et Al. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 158244 : August 9, 2005
Ernesto Ponce, Et Al. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 158919 : August 9, 2005
Republic of the Philippines, Et Al. vs. Maxima Lensico, Et Al.

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 160391 : August 9, 2005
Dusit Hotel Nikko, Et Al. vs. National Union of Workers in Hotel, Restaurant and Allied Industries ' Dusit Hotel Nikko Chapter, Et Al.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 161608 : August 9, 2005
Leoncio A. Amadore vs. Alberto G. Romulo, Et Al.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


A.C. No. 3441 : August 11, 2005
Judge Gervacio A. Lopena vs. Atty. Artemio P. Cabatos.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1601 : August 11, 2005
Mercedes G. Duduaco vs. Judge Lily Lydia A. Laquindanum.

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 132887 : August 11, 2005
The Manila Banking Corporation vs. Edmundo S. Silverio, Et Al.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 134342 : August 11, 2005
Evelyn Panahon vs. People of the Philippines.

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 148235 : August 11, 2005
Rosalina Tagle vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 148862 : August 11, 2005
Rubin Tad-y y Babor vs. People of the Philippines.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 148923 : August 11, 2005
Vicente Lamis, Et Al. vs. David Y. Ong.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 153667 : August 11, 2005
Ayala Land vs. Hon. Lucenito N. Tagle, Et Al.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 154818 : August 11, 2005
Stanley Garments Specialist, Et Al. vs. George Gomez, Et Al.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 156015 : August 11, 2005
Republic of the Philippines, Et Al. vs. Hon. Victorino Evangelista, Et Al.

Decision

J . Puno


G.R. No. 161379 : August 11, 2005
Ma. Teresa Belonio vs. Richard Rodriguez, Et Al.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 143312 : August 12, 2005
Ricardo S. Silverio, Jr., Et Al. vs. Filipino Business Consultants, Inc.

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 148288 : August 12, 2005
Rosemarie Balba vs. Peak Development Inc., Et Al.

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 148482 : August 12, 2005
Joseph Dorman D. Tamayo, Et Al. vs. Jose D. Tamayo, Jr., Et Al.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 149999 : August 12, 2005
The National Appellate Board (NAB) of the National Police Commission vs. P/Insp. John A. Mamauag, Et Al.

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 153762 : August 12, 2005
Susan Honoridez, Et Al. vs. Makilito B. Mahinay, Et Al.

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 156169 : August 12, 2005
Victor Ongson Vs. People of the Philippines.

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 158139 : August 12, 2005
Nelson P. Patulot vs. Jose L. Umali, Et Al.

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 159170 : August 12, 2005
Equitable PCIBank, Et Al. vs. Generosa A. Caguioa.

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 161976 : August 12, 2005
Central Luzon Conference Corporation of Seventh-Day Adventist Church, Inc., Et Al. vs. Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 163981 : August 12, 2005
Construction & Development Corporation of the Philippines vs. Rodolfo M. Cuenca, Et Al.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.C. No. 5499 : August 16, 2005
Wilson Po Cham vs. Atty. Edilberto D. Pizarro.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


A.M. No. 00-2-65-RTC : August 16, 2005
RE: Report on the ON-The-SPOT JUDICIAL AUDIT conducted in the RTC-Branches 45 and 53, Bacolod City.

Resolution

J . Austria-Martinez


A.M. No. P-04-1908 : August 16, 2005
Wilmer Salazar vs. Susan A. Limeta.


G.R. No. 132197 : August 16, 2005
Rosa Rica Sales Center, Inc., Et Al. vs. Spouses Gerry Ong, Et Al.


G.R. No. 134493 : August 16, 2005
Buencamino Cruz vs. The Honorable Sandiganbayan, Et Al.


G.R. No. 141709 : August 16, 2005
Manuel Raises vs. The Employees Compensation Commission, Et Al.


G.R. No. 147550 : August 16, 2005
Isidra Vda. De Victoria vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al.


G.R. No. 151899 : August 16, 2005
Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company, Inc. vs. Province of Laguna, Et Al.


G.R. No. 152356 : August 16, 2005
San Miguel Corporation vs. Mandaue Packing Products Plants-San Packaging Products ' San Miguel Corporation Monthlies Rank and File Union.

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 152532 : August 16, 2005
People of the Philippines vs. Sandiganbayan, Et Al.

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 154060 : August 16, 2005
Yusen Air and Sea Service Philippines, Incorporated vs. Isagani A. Villamor.


G.R. No. 154942 : August 16, 2005
Rolando Santos vs. Constancia Santos Alana.


G.R. No. 155555 : August 16, 2005
Isabel P. Portugal, Et Al. vs. Leonila Portugal-Beltran.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 156474 : August 16, 2005
Pesane Animas Mongao vs. Pryce Properties Corporation.

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 160929-31 : August 16, 2005
Rene P. Pondevida vs. The Hon. Sandiganbayan, Et Al.


A.M. No. 04-8-195-MCTC : August 18, 2005
RE: Financial Audit on the Accountabilities of Mr. Restituto A. Tabucon, Jr.

Decision

J . Carpio


A.M. No. 04-10-637-RTC : August 18, 2005
Disapproved Appointment of Maricel A. Cubijano.

Decision

Per Curiam


A.M. No. MTJ-02-1421 : August 18, 2005
Prosecutor Angelito V. Lumabas vs. Judge Emmanuel G. Banzon.

Decision

J . Azcuna


A.M. No. MTJ-04-1553 : August 25, 2005
Violeta N. Beltran vs. Judge Jaime D. Rafer.


G.R. No. 127383 : August 18, 2005
The City of Davao, Et Al. vs. The Regional Trial Court,


G.R. No. 141505 : August 18, 2005
Norma Hermogenes vs. Osco Shipping Services, Inc.

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 142474 : August 18, 2005
R.N. Symaco Trading Corporation, Et Al. vs. Luisito T. Santos.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 142810 : August 18, 2005
Dolores A. Cabello, Et Al. vs. The Republic of the Philippines.

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 143254 : August 18, 2005
Justina Cosipe Sigaya, Et Al. vs. Diomer Mayuga, Et Al.


G.R. No. 150739 : August 18, 2005
Spouses Benigno Que, Et Al. vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al.


G.R. No. 164801 : August 18, 2005
Philippine National Bank vs. Heirs of Estanislao Militar, Et Al.


G.R. No. 165253 : August 18, 2005
Civil Service Commission vs. Bernabet A. Maala.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


A.M. No. P-05-2059 : August 19, 2005
Atty. Audie C. Arnado vs. Edilberto R. Suarin.

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. P-05-2061 : August 19, 2005
Marcial Galahad T. Makasiar vs. Fe L. Gomintong.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 137881 : August 19, 2005
Isaac Delgado, Et Al. vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al.


G.R. No. 143558 : August 19, 2005
Isidro Lustaa vs. Araceli Jimena-Lazo.

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 153063-70 : August 19, 2005
Amelia D. De Mesa, Et Al. vs. Pepsi Cola Products Phils., Inc., Et Al.

Resolution

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 154002 : August 19, 2005
Philippine Scout Veterans Security & Investigation Agency, Inc. vs. Jose Pascua.


G.R. No. 159821 : August 19, 2005
Philippine Fisheries Development Authority vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al.


G.R. No. 168159 : August 19, 2005
Norkis Trading Co., Inc., Et Al. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al.

Resolution

J . Chico-Nazario


A.M. MTJ-04-1566 : August 22, 2005

Rita M. Melecio vs. Tyrone V. Tan, Sheriff IV, Regional Trial Court-Office of the Clerk of Court, Malaybalay City, Bukidnon.

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 140150 : August 22, 2005
Association of Integrated Security Force of Bislig, vs. Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 143866 : August 22, 2005
Poliand Industrial Limited vs. National Development Company, Et Al.

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 153699 : August 22, 2005
Cirse Francisco 'Choy Torralba vs. People of the Philippines.


G.R. No. 159270 : August 22, 2005
Philippine National Construction Corporation vs. Honorable Court of Appeals.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 164938 : August 22, 2005
Victor C. Agustin vs. Honorable Fernando Vil Pamintuan, Et Al.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. 2004-33-SC : August 24, 2005
Concerned Employee vs. Mr. Reynaldo B. Generoso, SC Supervising Judicial Staff Officer, Systems Planning and Project Management, MISO.


A.C. No. 6708 : August 25, 2005
Felicitas S. Quiambao vs. Atty. Nestor A. Bamba.


A.M. No. 05-7-458-RTC : August 25, 2005
Anonymous Complaint Against Sheriff Sales T. Bisnar.


A.M. No. RTJ-01-1660 : August 25, 2005
Office of the Court Administrator vs. Judge Maximo G. W. Paderanga.


A.M. No. RTJ-05-1945 : August 25, 2005
Sps . John & Annabelle F. Chan vs. Judge Jane Aurora C. Lantion.


G.R. No. 126207 : August 25, 2005
Amante O. San Pedro vs. Marciano M. Binalay.


G.R. No. 129928 : August 25, 2005
Misamis Occidental II Cooperative, Inc. vs. Virgilio S. David.


G.R. No. 139303 : August 25, 2005
Cipriano Enriquez, Et Al. vs. Maximo Enriquez.


G.R. No. 142347 : August 25, 2005
Dulce M. Abanilla vs. Commission on Audit, Et Al.


G.R. No. 144071 : August 25, 2005
Spouses Alejandro A. Joson, Et Al. vs. Reynaldo Mendoza, Et Al.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 149758 : August 25, 2005
Philex Gold Philippines, Inc., Et Al. vs. Philex Bulawan Supervisors Union.


G.R. No. 156057 : August 25, 2005
Pablo Borbon Memorial Institute of Technology, Et Al. vs.Conchita Albistor Vda. De Bool.


G.R. No. 157847 : August 25, 2005
Republic of the Philippines vs. Leodigario Sarabia, Et Al.


G.R. No. 158971 : August 25, 2005
Mariano Y. Siy vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al.

Resolution

J . Corona


G.R. No. 160354 : August 25, 2005
Banco De Oro Universal Bank vs. The Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al.


G.R. No. 160792 : August 25, 2005
In the Matter of the Petition for Habeas Corpus of Capt. Gary Alejano, Et Al. vs. Gen. Pedro Cabuay, Et Al.


G.R. No. 161760 : August 25, 2005
LBC Express, Inc., Et Al. vs. Spouses Euberto and Sisinia Ado.


G.R. No. 162371 : August 25, 2005
Mary Helen Estrada vs. People of the Philippines, Et Al.

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 162814-17 : August 25, 2005
Jose F. Manacop, Et Al. vs. Equitable PCIBank, Et Al.


G.R. No. 162822 : August 25, 2005
Jaime Guinhawa vs. People of the Philippines.


G.R. No. 165177 : August 25, 2005
Lilia V. Peralta-Labrador vs. Silverio Bugarin.


G.R. No. 166111 : August 25, 2005
Standard Electric Manufacturing Corporation vs. Standard Electric Employees Union-NAFLU-KMU, Et Al.


G.R. No. 132260 : August 30, 2005
Amante Siapno, Et Al., vs. Manuel V. Manalo.


G.R. No. 145264 : August 30, 2005
Napoleon Portes, Sr., Et Al.. vs. Segunda Arcala, Et Al.


G.R. No. 151900 : August 30, 2005
Christine Chua vs. Jorge Torres, Et Al.


G.R. No. 159482 : August 30, 2005
Nicasio P. Rodriguez, Jr., Et Al. vs. Antonio L. Aguilar, Sr.

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. 160531 : August 30, 2005
L & L Lawrence Footwear, Et Al. Vs. PCI Leasing and Finance Corporation.

Decision

J . Panganiban


A.M. No. 05-8-514-RTC : August 31, 2005
RE: Absence Without Official Leave of Mr. Jayson S. Tayros.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


A.M. No. P-05-2067 : August 31, 2005
Sps . Raymund and Julie Ann Mioso vs. Freddie Pamulag.


A.M. No. RTJ-04-1839 : August 31, 2005
Alberto P. Abbariao vs. Judge Orlando D. Beltran.

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 111388 : August 31, 2005
Jose Ingusan, Et Al. vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Corona


G.R. No. 123450 : August 31, 2005
Gerardo B. Concepcion vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Corona


G.R. No. 131966 : August 31, 2005
Republic of the Philippines vs. Hon. Aniano A. Desierto, Et Al.

Resolution

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 132477 : August 31, 2005
Jose Luis Ros, Et Al. vs. Department of Agrarian Reform, Et Al.


G.R. No. 143721 : August 31, 2005
Teresita E. Villaluz vs. Rolando R. Ligon.

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 144103 : August 31, 2005
Agueda De Vera-Cruz, Et Al. vs. Sabina Miguel.

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 144740 : August 31, 2005
Security Pacific Assurance Corporation vs. The Hon. Amelia Tria-Infante, Et Al.


G.R. No. 148632 : August 31, 2005
Belen Dela Torre vs. Bicol University.


G.R. No. 151060 : August 31, 2005
JN Development Corporation, Et Al. vs. Philippine Export and Foreign Loan Gurantee Corporation.

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 153204 : August 31, 2005
Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Manila Mining Corporation.


G.R. No. 154413 : August 31, 2005
Sps . Alfredo R. Edrada, Et Al. vs. Sps. Eduardo Ramos, Et Al.


G.R. No. 155099 : August 31, 2005
Security Bank Corporation vs. Judge Manuel D. Victorio, Et Al.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 156994 : August 31, 2005
Bank of the Philippine Islands vs. Ramon A. Uy.


G.R. No. 157141 : August 31, 2005
Sps . Rodrigo Lacierda, Et Al. vs. Dr. Rolando Platon, Et Al.


G.R. No. 157971 : August 31, 2005
Tristan Lopez vs. Leticia R. Fajardo.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 161048 : August 31, 2005
Basilisa Dungaran vs. Arleni Koschnicke.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 161286 : August 31, 2005
Spouses Narciso Rayoan, Et Al. vs. Allan Fronda, Et Al.

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 161955 : August 31, 2005
Celedonio Moldes, Et Al. vs. Tiburcio Villanueva, Et Al.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 164823 : August 31, 2005
Maria Carlos vs. Republic of the Philippines.


G.R. No. 168220 : August 31, 2005
Sps . Rudy Paragas, Et Al. vs. Hrs. of Dominador Balacano.

Resolution

J . Chico-Nazario



























chanrobles.com





ChanRobles Legal Resources:

ChanRobles On-Line Bar Review

ChanRobles Internet Bar Review : www.chanroblesbar.com

ChanRobles MCLE On-line

ChanRobles Lawnet Inc. - ChanRobles MCLE On-line : www.chanroblesmcleonline.com