ChanRobles Virtual law Library




SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

google search for chanrobles.comSearch for www.chanrobles.com

PLEASE CLICK HERE FOR THE LATEST ➔ SUPREME COURT DECISIONS







March 2005 – PHILIPPINE SUPREME COURT DECISIONS



A.M. No. 2004-40-SC : March 1, 2005
In RE: Complaint for Failure to Pay Just Debts Against Ms. Esther T. Andres

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


A.C. No. 5525 : March 4, 2005
Consolidated Farms, Inc. vs. Atty. Crisanto E. Alpon, Jr

Resolution

J . Garcia


A.C. No. 6424 : March 4, 2005
Consorcia S. Rollon vs. Atty. Camilo Naraval

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 135222 : March 4, 2005
Peter Andrada vs. The People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 138567 : March 4, 2005
Development Bank of the Philippines vs. Spouses Wilfredo Gatal, Et Al

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 142762 : March 4, 2005
Liliany Yulo y Billiones vs. The People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 146486 : March 4, 2005
Office of the Ombudsman vs. Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 149357 : March 4, 2005
Mobilia Products, Inc. vs. Hajime Umezawa

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 151245 : March 4, 2005
Ken Martin Clemente, Et Al. vs. Antonio Razo, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 152978 : March 4, 2005
Anicia U. Tecson, Et Al. vs. Dante Gutierrez

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 155419 : March 4, 2005
Hon. Aniano A. Desierto, Et Al. vs. Olivo C. Ocampo

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 158615 : March 4, 2005
Spouses Fortunata V. Baniqued, Et Al. vs. Teresita S. Ramos, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.C. No. 4018 : March 8, 2005
Omar P. Ali vs. Atty. Mosib A. Bubong

Decision

Per Curiam


A.M. No. P-03-1736 : March 8, 2005
Office of the Court Administrator vs. Clerk of Court Ma. Luisa V. Lising, Et Al

Resolution

Per Curiam


G.R. Nos. 96027-28 : March 8, 2005
Brig. Gen. Luther A. Custodio, Et Al. vs. Sandiganbayan, Et Al

Resolution

J . Puno


G.R. No. 124378 : March 8, 2005
National Power Corporation vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 157788 : March 8, 2005
St. Mary's University vs.Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 163448 : March 8, 2005
National Food Authority, Et Al. vs. Masada Security Agency, Inc

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. MTJ-04-1541 : March 10, 2005
Spouses Jesus V. Jacinto, Et Al. vs. Judge Placido V. Vallarta

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. RTJ-03-1785 : March 10, 2005
Danilo Espineli vs. 'Judge Dolores L. Espaol

Resolution

J . Corona


G.R. No. 124856 : March 10, 2005
De Castro Homesite, Inc. vs. Hon. Emilio L. Leachon, Jr., Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 140425 : March 10, 2005
Jesse Young vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 144801 : March 10, 2005
Dominador L. Taruc, Et Al. vs. Bishop Porfirio B. De La Cruz, Et Al

Decision

J . Corona


G.R. No. 154308 : March 10, 2005
Bernardino A. Caingat vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 156260 : March 10, 2005
Babcock-Hitachi (Phils.), Inc. vs. Babcock-Hitachi (Phils.), Inc. Makati Employees Union

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 161776 : March 10, 2005
Allied Banking Corporation, Et Al. vs. Spouses David E. Eserjose, Et Al

Resolution

J . Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 161865 : March 10, 2005
Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Monet's Export and Manufacturing Corporation, Et Al

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. MTJ-04-1564 : March 11, 2005
Alvin C. Go vs. Judge Rio Concepcion Achas

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1583 : March 11, 2005
Manuel B. Arcenas vs. Judge Henry B. Avelino

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 141882 : March 11, 2005
J.L.T. Agro, Inc. vs. Antonio Balansag, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. Nos. 146646-49 : March 11, 2005
Rogelio M. Esteban vs. The Sandiganbayan, Et Al

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 146780 : March 11, 2005
Dennis A. Chua vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 149349 : March 11, 2005
Glaxo Wellcome Philippines, Inc. vs. Nagkakaisang Empleyado ng Wellcome-DFA, Et Al

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 149751 : March 11, 2005
Purificacion Balilo Montero, Et Al. vs. Eugenio Septimo, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 153802 : March 11, 2005
Homeowners Savings & Loan Bank vs. Miguela C. Dailo

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 159252 : March 11, 2005
People of the Philippines vs. Rosario 'Rose Ochoa

Resolution

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 161227 : March 11, 2005
Lito T. Pasi, Et Al. vs. Francisco Salapong, Jr., Et Al

Decision

J . Puno


G.R. No. 161861 : March 11, 2005
Sps . William and Julie Lim, Et Al. vs. Eduardo Chuatoco, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


A.M. No. MTJ-03-1501 : March 14, 2005
Jaime Lim Co vs. Judge Ruben R. Plata

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 148599 : March 14, 2005
Professional Academic Plans, Inc., Et Al. vs. Dinnah L. Crisostomo

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 156804 : March 14, 2005
Sony Music Entertainment Inc., Et Al. vs. Hon. Judge Dolores L. Espaol, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 158324 : March 14, 2005
Roberto Ravago vs. Esso Eastern Marine, Ltd., Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. 2005-03-SC : March 15, 2005
RE: Unauthorized Absences of Karen R. Cuenca

Resolution

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.C. No. 5485 : March 16, 2005
Elmer Canoy vs. Atty. Jose Max Ortiz

Decision

J . Tinga


A.M. No. P-04-1857 : March 16, 2005
Merlinda L. Dagooc vs. Roberto A. Erlina

Resolution

J . Corona


G.R. No. 112526 : March 16, 2005
Sta. Rosa Realty Development Corporation vs. Juan B. Amante, Et Al

Amended Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 140746 : March 16, 2005
Pantranco North Express, Inc., Et Al. vs. Standard Insurance Company, Inc., Et Al

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 147941 : March 16, 2005
Nestor V. Blanco vs. Philippine Automotive Mfg. Corp

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 149580 : March 16, 2005
Rosario Dalton-Reyes vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 155791 : March 16, 2005
Melba Quinto vs. Dante Andres, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 157752 : March 16, 2005
Sally Miguel, Et Al. vs. JCT Group, Inc., Et Al

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 159699 : March 16, 2005
Rosalino P. Acance vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. P-03-1693 : March 17, 2005
Salvador P. De Guzman, Jr. vs. Antonio O. Mendoza

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. MTJ-03-1500 : March 18, 2005
Leonardo P. Dadula vs. Judge Manuel V. Ginete

Resolution

J . Austria-Martinez


A.M. No. MTJ-04-1525 : March 18, 2005
Rufino Casimiro vs. Judge Octavio Fernandez, Et Al

Resolution

J . Carpio-Morales


A.M. No. P-04-1880 : March 18, 2005
Office of the Court Administrator vs. Mr. Francisco P. Baguio

Resolution

J . Quisumbing


A.M. No. P-05-1973 : March 18, 2005
Equitable PCI Bank, Inc. vs. Antonio A. Bellones, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 119107 : March 18, 2005
Jose V. Lagon vs. Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Corona


G.R. No. 128122 : March 18, 2005
Premiere Development Bank vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 139254 : March 18, 2005
Social Security System vs. Department of Agrarian Reform, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 141658 : March 18, 2005
Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. The Philippine American Accident Insurance Company, Inc., Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 143666 : March 18, 2005
Soledad Mendoza, Et Al. vs. Purita Bautista

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 144148 : March 18, 2005
Sps . Feliza Duyan Gomez, Et Al. vs. Purisima Duyan, Et Al

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 144939 : March 18, 2005
Voyeur Visage Studio, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 145443 : March 18, 2005
Raquel P. Consulta vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 146531 : March 18, 2005
Domingo R. Manalo vs. PAIC Savings Bank, Et Al

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 147820 : March 18, 2005
Spouses Ruben Santiago, Et Al. vs. Merchants Rural Bank of Talavera, Inc

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 150222 : March 18, 2005
Moises G. Molen, Jr., Et Al. vs. Commission on Audit, Et Al

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 151987 : March 18, 2005
Director Fredric Villanueva, Et Al. vs. The Commission on Audit

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 152429 : March 18, 2005
Elizabeth Ed. Lim vs. Edilberto D. Ang

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 153743 : March 18, 2005
Norma B. Domingo vs. Yolanda Robles, Et Al

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 153832 : March 18, 2005
Filipinas Pre-fabricated Building Systems (Filsystems), Inc., Et Al. vs. Roger D. Puente

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 155477 : March 18, 2005
Municipality of La Libertad, Negros Oriental vs. Judith C. Penaflor

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 159411 : March 18, 2005
Teodoro I. Chavez vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Puno


A.C. No. 5878 : March 21, 2005
Jesus E. Santayana vs. Atty. Eliseo B. Alampay

Resolution

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


A.M. No. P-02-1567 : March 28, 2005
Hilario Tudtud, Et Al. vs. Atty. Rey D. Caayon

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 128305 : March 28, 2005
Felino Quiambao vs. The Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 128338 : March 28, 2005
Tining Resuena, Et Al. vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 131394 : March 28, 2005
Jesus V. Lanuza, Et Al. vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 143768 : March 28, 2005
Zosimo Perez, Et Al. vs. Democrito Perez, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 143998 : March 28, 2005
Mercury Drug Corporation vs. Araceli Domingo.


G.R. No. 144694 : March 28, 2005
Rudy P. Antonio, Et Al. vs. Hon. Francisco A. Villa, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 150859 : March 28, 2005
Florentino Gonzales, Et Al. vs. Balikatan Kilusang Bayan sa Pananalapi, Incorporated

Resolution

J . QUisumbing


G.R. No. 151378 : March 28, 2005
Jaka Food Processing Corporation vs. Darwin Pacot, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia

Separate Opinion

J. Tinga


G.R. No. 157033 : March 28, 2005
Gerardo O. Lanuza, Jr. vs. Ma. Vivian Yuchengco, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


P.E.T. Case No. 002 : March 29, 2005
Ronald Allan Poe vs. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo

Resolution

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 159966 : March 30, 2005
In Re: Petition for Change of Name and/or Correction/Cancellation of Entry in Civil Registry of Julian Lin Carulasan Wang vs. Cebu City Civil Registrar

Decision

J . Tinga


A.C. No. 5128 : March 31, 2005
Elesio C. Pormento, Sr. vs. Atty. Elias A. Pontevedra

Resolution

J . Austria-Martinez


A.M. No. MTJ-02-1461 : March 31, 2005
Ma. Teresa D. Columbres vs. Judge Aniceto L. Madronio

Resolution

J . Garcia


A.M. No. MTJ-04-1556 : March 31, 2005
Purita Lim vs. Judge Cesar M. Dumlao

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1584 : March 31, 2005
Maria Lilia Zarate vs. Judge Cesar O. Untalan, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1585 : March 31, 2005
Atty. Jose C. Claro vs. Judge Ramon V. Efondo.


A.M. No. P-05-1978 : March 31, 2005
Atty. Florante S. Legaspi vs. Alejandro L. Tobillo

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 122855 : March 31, 2005
Metro Iloilo Water District vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 127358 : March 31, 2005
Noel Buenaventura vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 133705 : March 31, 2005
C-J Yulo & Sons, Inc. vs. Roman Catholic Bishop of San Pablo, Inc

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 136211. 'March 31, 2005
Heirs of Vicente Hidalgo, Sr. vs. Department of Agrarian Reform

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 136975 : March 31, 2005
Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Hantex Trading Co., Inc

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 137775 : March 31, 2005
FGU Insurance Corporation vs. The Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 137863 : March 31, 2005
Bank of the Philippine Islands Employees Union, Et Al. vs. Bank of the Philippine Islands, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 138792-804 : March 31, 2005
Dante Guevarra, Et Al. vs. The Hon. Fourth Division of the Sandiganbayan, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 139912 : March 31, 2005
Yupangco Cotton Mills, Inc. vs. Rodrigo Sy Mendoza, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 139984 : March 31, 2005
Leopoldo Oani vs. People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 139987 : March 31, 2005
Salvador D. Flor vs. People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 140079 : March 31, 2005
Augusto R. Samalio vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Corona


G.R. No. 145013 : March 31, 2005
Spouses Berto Villorente, Et Al. vs. Aplaya Laiya Corporation

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 145823 : March 31, 2005
Oscar Maccay, Et Al. vs. Spouses Prudencio Nobela, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 147245 : March 31, 2005
The Republic of the Philippines vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 147958 : March 31, 2005
Aida Lugayan, Et Al. vs. Spouses Corazon and Antonio Tizon

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 148311 : March 31, 2005
In the Matter of Adoption of Stephanie Nathy Astorga Garcia

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 148376 : March 31, 2005
Leonardo Acabal, Et Al. vs. Villaner Acabal, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 148641 : March 31, 2005
PCI Leasing and Finance, Inc. vs. Emily Rose Go Ko, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 150321 : March 31, 2005
Adelina Guerzon Barcenas, Et Al. vs. Spouses Anastacio Tomas, Et Al

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 150798 : March 31, 2005
Rudecon Management Corporation vs. Sisenando S. Singson

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 154159 : March 31, 2005
People of the Philippines vs. Aloma Reyes, Et Al

Decision

J . Puno


G.R. No. 155110 : March 31, 2005
Habagat Grill vs. DMC-Urban Property Developer, Inc

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 155736 : March 31, 2005
Spouses Danilo and Cristina Decena vs. Spouses Pedro, Et Al

Resolution

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 156403 : March 31, 2005
Josephine Pahamotang, Et Al. vs. The Philippine National Bank, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 158000 : March 31, 2005
Association of International Shipping Lines, Inc., Et Al. vs. Philippine Ports Authority, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 158203 : March 31, 2005
People of the Philippines vs. Rico Calumpang, Et Al

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 158232 : March 31, 2005
Fujitsu Computer Products Corporation of the Philippines, Et Al. Vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al.

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 158251 : March 31, 2005
Hanford Philippines Incorporated, Et Al. vs. Shirley Joseph.


G.R. No. 160368 : March 31, 2005
Philippine Commercial Industrial Bank vs. Pedro L. Cabrera

Decision

C.J. , Davide, Jr.


G.R. No. 165491 : March 31, 2005
Roberto E. Olanolan vs. Commission on Elections, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


P.E.T. Case No. 003 : March 31, 2005
Loren B. Legarda vs. Noli L. De Castro

Resolution

J . Quisumbing



























chanrobles.com