TABLE
OF CONTENTS
SAMPLE/REPRESENTATIVE FULL
TEXT COPIES
OF THE
PHILIPPINE
SUPREME COURT
2004 DECISIONS
___________________________________________________________________________________
Featured Decisions
|
- JAIME
C. TARAN VS. JUDGE JOSE S. JACINTO, JR.
A.M.
No. MTJ-02-1436 [January 12, 2004]
- INFORMATION
TECHNOLOGY FOUNDATION OF THE PHILIPPINES, MA. CORAZON M. AKOL, MIGUEL
UY,
EDUARDO H. LOPEZ, AUGUSTO C. LAGMAN, REX C. DRILON, MIGUEL HILADO, LEY
SALCEDO AND MANUEL ALCUAZ JR. VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS;
COMELEC
CHAIRMAN BENJAMIN ABALOS SR.; COMELEC BIDDING and AWARD COMMITTEE
CHAIRMAN
EDUARDO D. MEJOS AND MEMBERS GIDEON DE GUZMAN, JOSE F. BALBUENA,
LAMBERTO
P. LLAMAS, AND BARTOLOME SINOCRUZ JR.; MEGA PACIFIC eSOLUTIONS, INC.;
AND
MEGA PACIFIC CONSORTIUM
G.R.
No. 159139 [January 13, 2004]
- DEVELOPMENT
BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. UNION BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES
G.R.
No. 155838 [January 13, 2004]
- LAND
BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. FELICIANO F. WYCOCO
G.R.
No. 140160 [January 13, 2004]
- FELICIANO
F. WYCOCO VS. THE HONORABLE RODRIGO S. CASPILLO, PAIRING JUDGE
OF
THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, THIRD JUDICIAL REGION, BRANCH 23, CABANATUAN
CITY AND THE DEPARTMENT OF AGRARIAN REFORM
G.R.
No. 146733 [January 13, 2004]
- AGUSTINA
M. ENEMECIO VS. OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN (VISAYAS) AND SERVANDO
BERNANTE
G.R.
No. 146731 [January 13, 2004]
- PHILIPPINE
BANKING CORPORATION VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND AMALIO L.
SARMIENTO,
DOING BUSINESS UNDER THE FIRM NAME "A.L. SARMIENTO CONSTRUCTION,"
G.R.
No. 133710 [January 13, 2004]
- SHOPPER’S
PARADISE REALTY & DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION VS. EFREN P. ROQUE
G.R.
No. 148775 [January 13, 2004]
- REPUBLIC
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. CHULE Y. LIM
G.R.
No. 153883 [January 13, 2004]
- IGLECERIO
MAHINAY VS. ATTY. GABINO A. VELASQUEZ, JR.
G.R.
No. 152753 [January 13, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. BUTCHOY DE LA TORRE AND FE DE LA TORRE
G.R.
Nos. 121213 and 121216-23 [January 13, 2004]
- PHILIPPINE
EXPORT AND FOREIGN LOAN GUARANTEE CORPORATION VS. PHILIPPINE
INFRASTRUCTURES,
INC., PHILIPPINE BRITISH ASSURANCE CO., INC., THE SOLID GUARANTY, INC.,
B.F. HOMES, INC., PILAR DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AND TOMAS F. AGUIRRE
G.R.
No. 120384 [January 13, 2004]
- TEODORA
A. RIOFERIO, VERONICA O. EVANGELISTA, ASSISTED BY HER HUSBAND, ZALDY
EVANGELISTA,
ALBERTO ORFINADA, AND ROWENA O. UNGOS, ASSISTED BY HER HUSBAND, BEDA
UNGOS VS.
COURT OF APPEALS, ESPERANZA P. ORFINADA, LOURDES P. ORFINADA, ALFONSO
ORFINADA,
NANCY P. ORFINADA, ALFONSO JAMES P. ORFINADA, CHRISTOPHER P. ORFINADA
AND
ANGELO P. ORFINADA
G.R.
No. 129008 [January 13, 2004]
- MANUEL
E. ZAMORA VS. GOVERNOR JOSE R. CABALLERO, ANESIO M. RANARIO, IN
HIS CAPACITY AS PROVINCIAL ADMINISTRATOR, MARIANO KINTANAR, IN HIS
CAPACITY
AS PROVINCIAL AUDITOR, CARMEN R. RASUL, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PROVINCIAL
TREASURER,
ROLANDO L. OSORIO, BELINDA G. APAWAN, ARMANDO L. SERAS, RUWEL PETER S.
GONZAGA, ARMANDO C. CODILLA, RAUL B. BASA, AND GRACIANO C. ARAFOL, JR.
G.R.
No. 147767 [January 14, 2004]
- ALEXANDER
P. RUGAS VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES
G.R.
No. 147789 [January 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. MARLON JUAN Y LESTE
G.R.
No. 152289 [January 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. MANNY A. DOMINGCIL
G.R.
No. 140679 [January 14, 2004]
- SHOPPES
MANILA, INC. VS. THE HON. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION,
LABOR
ARBITER ERMITA ABRASALDO-CUYUCA AND LORIE TORNO
G.R.
No. 147125 [January 14, 2004]
- MEL
V. VELARDE VS. LOPEZ, INC.
G.R.
No. 153886 [January 14, 2004]
- JULIE
PARCON SONG VS. ROMEO LLEGUE
A.M.
No. CA-02-34 [January 14, 2004]
- SENATOR
ROBERT S. JAWORSKI VS. PHILIPPINE AMUSEMENT AND GAMING
CORPORATION
AND SPORTS AND GAMES ENTERTAINMENT CORPORATION
G.R.
No. 144463 [January 14, 2004]
- THE
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. CLEMENTINO LOU Y GALINDO ALIAS
"JUNIOR"
G.R.
No. 146803 [January 14, 2004]
- DORCAS
G. PETALLAR VS. JUDGE JUANILLO M. PULLOS, MCTC, SAN FRANCISCO,
SURIGAO
DEL NORTE
A.M.
No. MTJ-03-1484 [January 15, 2004]
- ADELFA
S. RIVERA, CYNTHIA S. RIVERA, AND JOSE S. RIVERA VS. FIDELA DEL
ROSARIO (DECEASED AND SUBSTITUTED BY HER CO-RESPONDENTS) AND HER
CHILDREN,
OSCAR, ROSITA, VIOLETA, ENRIQUE JR., CARLOS, JUANITO AND ELOISA, ALL
SURNAMED
DEL ROSARIO
G.R.
No. 144934 [January 15, 2004]
- OCCIDENTAL
MINDORO NATIONAL COLLEGE (OMNC) AND OFELIA A. REBONG VS.
VIRGINIA
P. MACARAIG
G.R.
No. 152017 [January 15, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. BENJAMIN SAYABOC Y SEGUBA, PATRICIO
ESCORPISO
Y VALDEZ, MARLON BUENVIAJE Y PINEDA, AND MIGUEL BUENVIAJE Y FLORES
G.R.
No. 147201 [January 15, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. JAIME BAÑO ALIAS "JIMMY"
G.R.
No. 148710 [January 15, 2004]
- DR.
MARCELO M. ALMANZOR AND VIENNA NANNY L. ALMANZOR VS. DR. BENITO
S. FELIX
G.R.
No. 144935 [January 15, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. JESSIELITO BADAJOS Y SUMBIDAN ALIAS
"TOTO"
AND FRETCHIE SANCHEZ Y AMPARO (AT LARGE)
G.R.
No. 139692 [January 15, 2004]
- ATTYS.
VILMA HILDA D. VILLANUEVA-FABELLA AND WILMAR T. ARUGAY VS.
JUDGE
RALPH S. LEE AND SHERIFF JUSTINIANO C. DE LA CRUZ JR., BOTH OF THE
METROPOLITAN
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 38, QUEZON CITY
A.M.
No. MTJ-04-1518 [January 15, 2004]
- ADONIS
ARADILLOS AND ALBINO GALABO VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND THE PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES, REPRESENTED BY THE OFFICE OF THE SOLICITOR GENERAL
G.R.
No. 135619 [January 15, 2004]
- FELICIDAD
B. DADIZON VS. JUDGE ENRIQUE C. ASIS
A.M.
No. RTJ-03-1760 [January 15, 2004]
- SPOUSES
ELIGIO P. MALLARI AND MARCELINA I. MALLARI VS. IGNACIO ARCEGA,
PERCASIO
CATACUTAN, BEN GARCIA, ALFREDO DE GUZMAN, MARIETA JACINTO, CELESTINO
MAGAT,
VICENTE MALLARI, RAFAEL MANALO, LORENZO MANARANG, EMILIO DE MESA, JUAN
PANGILINAN, TOROBIA SERRANO, CELESTINA TORNO AND JUANITO VITAL
G.R.
No. 106615 [January 15, 2004]
- IGNACIO
ARCEGA, PERCASIO CATACUTAN, BEN GARCIA, ALFREDO DE GUZMAN, MARIETA
JACINTO,
CELESTINO MAGAT, VICENTE MALLARI, RAFAEL MANALO, LORENZO MANARANG,
EMILIO
DE MESA, JUAN PANGILINAN, TOROBIA SERRANO, CELESTINA TORNO AND JUANITO
VITAL VS. HONORABLE NORBERTO C. PONCE, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
JUDGE,
BRANCH XLVI, SAN FERNANDO, PAMPANGA AND SPOUSES ELIGIO MALLARI AND
MARCELINA
MALLARI
G.R.
No. 108591 [January 15, 2004]
- SPOUSES
ELIGIO P. MALLARI AND MARCELINA I. MALLARI VS. IGNACIO ARCEGA,
ALFREDO
DE GUZMAN, PERCASIO CATACUTAN, RAFAEL MANALO, EMILIO DE MESA, JUANITO
VITAL,
TOROBIA SERRANO, CELESTINO MAGAT, VICENTE MALLARI, LORENZO MANARANG,
MARIETA
JACINTO, BEN GARCIA, CELESTINA TORNO AND JUAN PANGILINAN
G.R.
No. 109452 [January 15, 2004]
- SPOUSES
ELIGIO P. MALLARI AND MARCELINA I. MALLARI VS. IGNACIO ARCEGA,
PERCASIO
CATACUTAN, BEN GARCIA, ALFREDO DE GUZMAN, MARIETA JACINTO, CELESTINO
MAGAT,
VICENTE MALLARI, RAFAEL MANALO, LORENZO MANARANG, EMILIO DE MESA, JUAN
PANGILINAN, TOROBIA SERRANO, CELESTINA TORNO AND JUANITO VITAL
G.R.
No. 109978 [January 15, 2004]
- SPOUSES
ELIGIO P. MALLARI AND MARCELINA I. MALLARI VS. IGNACIO ARCEGA,
PERCASIO
CATACUTAN, BEN GARCIA, ALFREDO DE GUZMAN, MARIETA JACINTO, CELESTINO
MAGAT,
VICENTE MALLARI, RAFAEL MANALO, LORENZO MANARANG, EMILIO DE MESA, JUAN
PANGILINAN, TOROBIA SERRANO, CELESTINA TORNO AND JUANITO VITAL
G.R.
No. 139379 [January 15, 2004]
- PROVIDENT
INSURANCE CORP. VS. HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS AND AZUCAR
SHIPPING
CORP.
G.R.
No. 118030 [January 15, 2004]
- ALFREDO
YASAY DEL ROSARIO VS. SPS. JOSE E. MANUEL AND CONCORDIA MANUEL,
REPRESENTED BY ATTORNEY-IN-FACT, PATRICIA ARIOLA
G.R.
No. 153652 [January 16, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. RESTY HORMINA
G.R.
No. 144383 [January 16, 2004]
- MALAYANG
SAMAHAN NG MANGGAGAWA SA BALANCED FOOD, NILO LETADA, FERNANDO FALLERA,
DANILO ESCARIO, BENEDICTO CARREON, CAMILO AGUILA, GERRY BAUTISTA,
FRIDAY
MENDOZA, MARINO TAYOTO, PEPE TUBELLO, ROLANDO SERRANO, MATIAS BAQUIRAN,
DAVID BALLESTEROS, RODOLFO PARAS, ROBERTO CABAEL AND CESAR OLISA VS.
PINAKAMASARAP CORPORATION, SY TIAN TIN, DR. SY TIN DIAN, DOMINGO TAN,
ROLANDO
REYES AND LOUIE VILLANUEVA
G.R.
No. 139068 [January 16, 2004]
- HEIRS
OF POMPOSA SALUDARES, REPRESENTED BY ISABEL DATOR VS. COURT OF
APPEALS,
JOSE DATOR AND CARMEN CALIMUTAN
G.R.
No. 128254 [January 16, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. DIONISIO SANTOS
G.R.
No. 127492 [January 16, 2004]
- CONCERNED
CITIZENS OF SAN FRANCISCO, SURIGAO DEL NORTE VS. HON. JUDGE
JUANILLO
M. PULLOS, CLERK OF COURT MANUEL D. GEALAN, CLERK OF COURT II ESMERALDA
L. ANGOB, STENOGRAPHERS I ROSARIO B. GASULAS AND ALMEA B. PAYUSAN,
MUNICIPAL
CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT, SAN FRANCISCO, MALIMONO, SURIGAO DEL NORTE
A.M.
No. MTJ-03-1507 [January 20, 2004]
- RE:
MISAPPROPRIATION OF THE JUDICIARY FUND COLLECTIONS BY MS. JULIET C.
BANAG,
CLERK OF COURT, MTC, PLARIDEL, BULACAN
A.M.
No. P-02-1641 [January 20, 2004]
- MILAGROS
M. BARCO, AS THE NATURAL GUARDIAN AND GUARDIAN AD LITEM OF MARY JOY ANN
GUSTILO VS. COURT OF APPEALS (SPECIAL SIXTEENTH DIVISION),
REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT (BR. 133-MAKATI), NCJR; THE LOCAL CIVIL REGISTRAR OF
MAKATI;
AND NADINA G. MARAVILLA
G.R.
No. 120587 [January 20, 2004]
- DEMOSTHENES
P. AGAN, JR., JOSEPH B. CATAHAN, JOSE MARI B. REUNILLA, MANUEL ANTONIO
B. BOÑE, MAMERTO S. CLARA, REUEL E. DIMALANTA, MORY V. DOMALAON,
CONRADO G. DIMAANO, LOLITA R. HIZON, REMEDIOS P. ADOLFO, BIENVENIDO C.
HILARIO, MIASCOR WORKERS UNION-NATIONAL LABOR UNION (MWU-NLU), AND
PHILIPPINE
AIRLINES EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION (PALEA) VS. PHILIPPINE
INTERNATIONAL
AIR TERMINALS CO., INC., MANILA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY,
DEPARTMENT
OF TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNICATIONS and SECRETARY LEANDRO M. MENDOZA,
IN HIS CAPACITY AS HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AND
COMMUNICATIONS
G.R.
No. 155001 [January 21, 2004]
- SALACNIB
F. BATERINA, CLAVEL A. MARTINEZ AND CONSTANTINO G. JARAULA VS.
PHILIPPINE
INTERNATIONAL AIR TERMINALS CO., INC., MANILA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
AUTHORITY,
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNICATIONS, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
WORKS
AND HIGHWAYS, SECRETARY LEANDRO M. MENDOZA, IN HIS CAPACITY AS HEAD OF
THE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNICATIONS, AND SECRETARY
SIMEON
A. DATUMANONG, IN HIS CAPACITY AS HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
WORKS
AND HIGHWAYS, RESPONDENTS, JACINTO V. PARAS, RAFAEL P. NANTES, EDUARDO
C. ZIALCITA, WILLY BUYSON VILLARAMA, PROSPERO C. NOGRALES, PROSPERO A.
PICHAY, JR., HARLIN CAST ABAYON, and BENASING O. MACARANBON
G.R.
No. 155547 [January 21, 2004]
- CEFERINO
C. LOPEZ, RAMON M. SALES, ALFREDO B. VALENCIA, MA. TERESA V. GAERLAN,
LEONARDO
DE LA ROSA, DINA C. DE LEON, VIRGIE CATAMIN, RONALD SCHLOBOM, ANGELITO
SANTOS, MA. LUISA M. PALCON AND SAMAHANG MANGGAGAWA SA PALIPARAN NG
PILIPINAS
(SMPP) VS. PHILIPPINE INTERNATIONAL AIR TERMINALS CO., INC.,
MANILA
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY, DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AND
COMMUNICATIONS,
SECRETARY LEANDRO M. MENDOZA, IN HIS CAPACITY AS HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNICATIONS
G.R.
No. 155661 [January 21, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. DOMINADOR CACHOLA Y SALAZAR, ERNESTO
AMAY
Y PASCUA, NESTOR MARQUEZ Y MANUEL, BENJAMIN LAEGEN Y CAMADO, RODOLFO
SAGUN
Y JIMENEZ, RODEMIR GUERZO Y LATAOAN, MELLKE IGNACIO Y SALVADOR, AND
NELSON
C. ECHABARIA
G.R.
Nos. 148712-15 [January 21, 2004]
- THE
LIGA NG MGA BARANGAY NATIONAL VS. THE CITY MAYOR OF MANILA,
HON.
JOSE ATIENZA, JR., AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF MANILA
G.R.
No. 154599 [January 21, 2004]
- DEVELOPMENT
BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. PINGOL LAND TRANSPORT SYSTEM
COMPANY,
INC., REMEDIOS D. PINGOL, ET AL.
G.R.
No. 145908 [January 22, 2004]
- BAILINANG
P. MAROHOMBSAR VS. JUDGE SANTOS B. ADIONG
A.M.
No. RTJ-02-1674 [January 22, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. BENHUR MAMARIL
G.R.
No. 147607 [January 22, 2004].
- MERCEDES
NAVA VS. ATTY. BENJAMIN P. SORONGON
A.C.
No. 5442 [January 26, 2004]
- ROYAL
CARGO CORPORATION VS. CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
G.R.
Nos. 103055-56 [January 26, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. NOEL DARILAY
G.R.
Nos. 139751-52 [January 26, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. ARSENIO DE JESUS, ET AL.
G.R.
Nos. 144080-81 [January 26, 2004]
- DR.
JOHN M. W. GRIEVE VS. JUDGE CORNELIO T. JACA
A.M.
No. MTJ-01-1351 [January 27, 2004].
- LA
BUGAL - B'LAAN TRIBAL ASSOCIATION, INC., REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN
F'LONG
MIGUEL M. LUMAYONG, ET AL. VS. VICTOR O. RAMOS, SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES (DENR), ET AL.
G.R.
No. 127882 [January 27, 2004]
- ESTATE
OF THE LATE JULIANA DIEZ VDA. DE GABRIEL VS. COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL
REVENUE
G.R.
No. 155541 [January 27, 2004]
- MANSUETO
CUATON VS. REBECCA SALUD and COURT OF APPEALS (Special
Fourteenth
Division)
G.R.
No. 158382 [January 27, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. FRANCISCO BLANCAFLOR
G.R.
No. 130586 [January 29, 2004]
- JOCELYN
V. GRAGEDA VS. JUDGE NIETO T. TRESVALLES, MUNICIPAL TRIAL
COURT,
VIRAC, CATANDUANES
A.M.
MTJ No. 04-1526 [February 02, 2004]
- HILDA
D. TABAS VS. ATTY. BONIFACIO B. MANGIBIN
A.C.
No. 5602 [February 3, 2004]
- DOLORES
IMBANG VS. JUDGE DEOGRACIAS K. DEL ROSARIO, MCTC, BRANCH 3,
PATNONGON,
ANTIQUE
A.M.
No. MTJ-03-1515 [February 3, 2004]
- VICENTE
FOLLOSCO AND HERMILINA FOLLOSCO VS. ATTY. RAFAEL MATEO
A.C.
No. 6186 [February 3, 2004]
- REX
M. FUENTEBELLA VS. CLERK OF COURT IV EDGARDO S. GELLADA, CLERK
IV
ANA DINAH L. PLANTA, AND CLERK III ELIZABETH G. OMBION
A.M.
No. P-04-1769 [February 5, 2004]
- ATTY.
VIRGILIA C. CARMAN, SPS. ELENITA LUSAYA AND DENNIS JARANGUE, AND PAZ
ALMACEN VS. JUDGE ALEXIS A. ZERRUDO, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN
CITIES (MTCC)
ZARRAGA-LEGANES-NEW LUCENA, BRANCH 3, ILOILO CITY, AND MA. THERESA G.
ZERRUDO,
ASSISTANT CLERK OF COURT, MTCC, ILOILO CITY
A.M.
No. MTJ-98-1146 [February 5, 2004]
- DARIO
MANALASTAS VS. JUDGE RODRIGO R. FLORES, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT,
BRANCH
2, SAN FRANCISCO, PAMPANGA
A.M.
No. MTJ-04-1523 [February 6, 2004]
- OCTAVIO
J. TRAYA, JR. VS. ATTY. FRANCISCO M. VILLAMOR
A.C.
No.4595 [February 6, 2004]
- INOCENCIO
M. MONTES VS. JUDGE EFREN B. MALLARE, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT,
STO.
DOMINGO, NUEVA ECIJA
A.M.
No. MTJ-04-1528 [February 6, 2004]
- GERALDINE
P. DIZON VS. HIYASMIN L. CAMPO, COURT STENOGRAPHER, MCTC -
CAPAS,
TARLAC
A.M.
No. P-04-1774 [February 9, 2004]
- FILOMENA
MENESES VS. ALBERTA S. ZARAGOZA, SHERIFF III, MeTC, BRANCH 45,
PASAY
CITY
A.M.
No. P-04-1768 [February 11, 2004]
- RUDY
T. SALCEDO VS. JUDGE AMADO S. CAGUIOA AND SHERIFF BIENVENIDO C.
ARAGONES, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES, BAGUIO CITY (BRANCH 3)
A.M.
No. MTJ-00-1328 [February 11, 2004]
- RE:
REPORT ON THE JUDICIAL AUDIT CONDUCTED IN THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT,
BRANCHES
3, 5, 7, 60 AND 61, BAGUIO CITY
A.M.
No. 02-9-568-RTC [February 11, 2004]
- CARLOMAGNO
V. TORIBIO VS. ATTY. FERMIN M. OFILAS, CLERK OF COURT VI AND
EX-OFICIO
SHERIFF, RTC-OCC, SAN MATEO, RIZAL
A.M.
No. P-03-1714 [February 13, 2004]
- JOVITA
BUSTAMANTE-ALEJANDRO VS. ATTYS. WARFREDO TOMAS ALEJANDRO AND
MARICRIS
A. VILLARIN
A.C.
No. 4256 [February 13, 2004]
- RODRIGO
Q. TUGOT VS. JUDGE MAMERTO Y. COLIFLORES
A.M.
No. MTJ-00-1332 [February 16, 2004]
- MILAGROS
N. ALDOVINO, VIRGILIO NICODEMUS, ANGELA N. DELA CRUZ, JULITA N. SOCO,
MAGDALENA
N. TALENS AND TEODORO S. NICODEMUS VS. ATTY. PEDRO C. PUJALTE,
JR.
A.C.
No. 5082 [February 17, 2004]
- AMADO
N. UBONGEN VS. VIRGINIA S. UBONGEN, COURT STENOGRAPHER III,
REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 219, QUEZON CITY
A.M.
No. P-04-1780 [February 18, 2004]
- SEVERO
A. CORDERO VS. JUSTICE JUAN Q. ENRIQUEZ, COURT OF APPEALS
A.M.
No. CA-04-36 [February 18, 2004]
- TEODORA
A. CAPACETE AND RODOLFO CAPACETE VS. JOEL O. ARELLANO, SHERIFF
IV,
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 25, BIÑAN, LAGUNA
A.M.
No. P-03-1700 [February 23, 2004]
- SERVILLANO
BATAC, JR. AND ANTONIO BONOAN VS. ATTY. PONCIANO V. CRUZ, JR.
A.C.
No. 5809 [February 23, 2004]
- ROMERO
TEODOSIO, ROLANDO RICO, AMADO BAUTISTA AND JESSIE BAUTISTA VS.
HON.
JUDGE ARTURO R. CARPIO, FIRST MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT (MCTC), NEW
WASHINGTON, AKLAN
A.
M. No. MTJ-02-1416 [February 27, 2004]
- FLORENCE
TEVES MACARRUBO, THE MINORS JURIS ALEXIS T. MACARRUBO AND GABRIEL
ENRICO
T. MACARRUBO AS REPRESENTED BY THEIR MOTHER/GUARDIAN, FLORENCE TEVES
MACARRUBO VS.
ATTY. EDMUNDO L. MACARRUBO
A.C.
No. 6148 [February 27, 2004]
- FRANCISCO
GALMAN CRUZ VS. JUSTICE PORTIA ALIÑO-HORMACHUELOS,
JUDGE VICTORIA FERNANDEZ-BERNARDO, JUDGE CAESAR A. CASANOVA, JUDGE
RENATO
C. FRANCISCO, JUDGE MANUEL D. J. SYCIANGCO AND JUDGE ESTER R. CHUA-YU
A.M.
No. CA-04-38 [March 31, 2004]
- DR.
FRANCISCA T. YOINGCO AND ATTY. NESCITO C. HILARIO VS.
HON.
CONCEPCION V. GONZAGA, PRESIDING JUDGE, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT OF STO.
TOMAS,
BATANGAS
A.M.
No. MTJ-03-1489 [March 31, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. SALVADOR GOLIMLIM ALIAS “BADONG”
G.
R. No. 145225 [April 2, 2004]
- JUDGE
JOSE C. REYES, JR., EXECUTIVE JUDGE, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT - SAN MATEO,
RIZAL VS. RICARDO CRISTI, CASH CLERK II, OFFICE OF THE CLERK OF
COURT, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT - SAN MATEO, RIZAL
A.M.
No. P-04-1801 [April 2, 2004]
- ATTY.
RAUL A. MUYCO VS. EVA B. SARATAN, BRANCH CLERK OF COURT, BRANCH
32, RTC, ILOILO CITY
A.M.
No. P-03-1761 [April 2, 2004]
- GREGORIO
B. HONASAN II VS. THE PANEL OF INVESTIGATING PROSECUTORS OF THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE (LEO DACERA, SUSAN F. DACANAY, EDNA A. VALENZUELA
AND SEBASTIAN F. CAPONONG, JR.), CIDG-PNP-P/DIRECTOR EDUARDO MATILLANO,
and HON. OMBUDSMAN SIMEON V. MARCELO
G.R.
No. 159747 [April 13, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. ANTONIO REYES Y MAGANO
G.R.
No. 153119 [April 13, 2004]
- REV.
ELLY CHAVEZ PAMATONG, ESQUIRE VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS
G.R.
No. 161872 [April 13, 2004]
- JOSEFINA
B. FAJARDO VS. ATTY. DANILO DELA TORRE
A.C.
No. 6295 [April 14, 2004]
- AKLAT-ASOSASYON
PARA SA KAUNLARAN NG LIPUNAN AT ADHIKAIN PARA SA TAO, INC. VS.
COMMISSION
ON ELECTIONS (COMELEC)
G.R.
No. 162203 [April 14, 2004]
- HON.
JULIETA A. DECENA, HON. VIRGILIO D. PONTANAL, HON. AMELITA A. IBASCO,
HON.
GERRY D. RAÑA, HON. PEDRO N. MORA. JR., AND HON. FERDINAND T.
AGUILAR VS.
JUDGE NILO A. MALANYAON, PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
(RTC),
BRANCH 32, PILI, CAMARINES SUR
AM
No. RTJ-02-1669 (Formerly OCA IPI No.00-961-RTJ) [April 14, 2004]
- HENRY
L. MON VS. COURT OF APPEALS, HON. LEOPOLDO SERRANO, JR., DEPARTMENT OF
AGRARIAN REFORM ADJUDICATION BOARD AND SPOUSES LARRY AND JOVITA VELASCO
G.R.
No. 118292 [April 14, 2004]
- MONDRAGON
LEISURE AND RESORTS CORPORATION VS. UNITED COCONUT PLANTERS BANK
G.R.
No. 154187 [April 14, 2004]
- ANSBERTO
P. PAREDES VS. FRANCISCO S. PADUA, CLERK III, COURT OF APPEALS
A.M.
No. CA-91-3-P [April 14, 2004]
- ISIDRO
IDULZA AND GODOFREDO CABANA VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS AND
TERESITA
A. BOLLOZOS, REY L. MORTIZ, MIGUEL P. PADERANGA, JOJAC Q. ASUNCION AND
CIFERINO L. GARCIA, JR.
G.R.
No. 160130 [April 14, 2004]
- EUGENIO
C. GONZALES, ET AL. VS. MARIANO S. FAMILARA III, CLERK OF
COURT,
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF ROXAS, (BRANCH 43), ORIENTAL MINDORO
A.M.
No. P-04-1794 (Formerly OCA IPI NO. 03-1626-P) [April 14, 2004]
- PHILIPS
SEMICONDUCTORS (PHILS.), INC. VS. ELOISA FADRIQUELA
G.R.
No. 141717 [April 14, 2004]
- AGILENT
TECHNOLOGIES SINGAPORE (PTE) LTD. VS. INTEGRATED SILICON
TECHNOLOGY
PHILIPPINES CORPORATION, TEOH KIANG HONG, TEOH KIANG SENG, ANTHONY
CHOO,
JOANNE KATE M. DELA CRUZ, JEAN KAY M. DELA CRUZ AND ROLANDO T. NACILLA
G.R.
No. 154618 [April 14, 2004]
- TEXON
MANUFACTURING AND BETTY CHUA VS. GRACE MILLENA AND MARILYN
MILLENA
G.R.
No. 141380 [April 14, 2004]
- ISIDRA
TING-DUMALI VS. ATTY. ROLANDO S. TORRES
A.C.
No. 5161 [April 14, 2004]
- REPUBLIC
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. CARMENCITA M. ALCONABA; LUISITO B.
MELENDEZ;
CONCEPCION M. LAZARO; MAURICIO B. MELENDEZ, JR.; AND MYRNA M. GALVEZ,
REPRESENTED
BY CONCEPCION M. LAZARO
G.R.
No. 155012 [April 14, 2004]
- JUDGE
NIMFA P. SITACA VS. ATTY. DIEGO M. PALOMARES
Adm.
Case No. 5285 [April 14, 2004]
- KINGSTON(E)
LI Y NUNEZ VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, AND THE
HONORABLE
COURT OF APPEALS
G.R.
No. 127962 [April 14, 2004]
- MARCELINA
VENZON VS. SPS. SANTOS AND GLORIA JUAN, DEPUTY SHERIFF VINCENT
F.
SUGUI AND THE REGISTER OF DEEDS OF VALENZUELA
G.R.
No. 128308 [April 14, 2004]
- PROCOPIO
VILLANUEVA, NICOLAS RETUYA AND PACITA VILLANUEVA VS. COURT OF
APPEALS
AND THE HEIRS OF EUSEBIA NAPISA RETUYA
G.R.
No. 143286 [April 14, 2004]
- PREMIERE
DEVELOPMENT BANK VS. COURT OF APPEALS, PANACOR MARKETING
CORPORATION
AND ARIZONA TRANSPORT CORPORATION
G.R.
No. 159352 [April 14, 2004]
- ANTONIO
K. LITONJUA AND AURELIO K. LITONJUA, JR. VS. MARY ANN GRACE
FERNANDEZ,
HEIRS OF PAZ TICZON ELEOSIDA, REPRESENTED BY GREGORIO T. ELEOSIDA,
HEIRS
OF DOMINGO B. TICZON, REPRESENTED BY MARY MEDIATRIX T. FERNANDEZ,
CRISTETA
TICZON, EVANGELINE JILL R. TICZON, ERLINDA T. BENITEZ, DOMINIC TICZON,
JOSEFINA LUISA PIAMONTE, JOHN DOES AND JANE DOES
G.R.
No. 148116 [April 14, 2004]
- BANK
OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS, AS SUCCESSOR-IN-INTEREST OF BPI INVESTMENT
CORPORATION VS.
ALS MANAGEMENT AND DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
G.R.
No. 151821 [April 14, 2004]
- ARIEL
C. VALLEJO VS. HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS, FORMER SPECIAL
FIFTEENTH
DIVISION, JUDGE ISAAC R. DE ALBAN, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, ILAGAN,
ISABELA,
BRANCH 16, AND FRANKLIN M. JAVIER, NBI HEAD AGENT, CAGAYAN VALLEY
REGIONAL
OFFICE II, ILAGAN, ISABELA
G.R.
No. 156413 [April 14, 2004]
- APOLONIA
LL. OCAMPO, NOW SUBSTITUTED BY MARIANO O. QUIEN, AMELITA Q. TAN,
MILOVAN
O. QUIEN, LUISA OCAMPO-LLORIN, MELITA F. OCAMPO, FELIX OCAMPO JR.,
RAMON
OCAMPO, MIGUEL OCAMPO, JUANA OCAMPO, ANDRES OCAMPO SR., VIOLETA OCAMPO,
MERCEDITA OCAMPO, ANTONIA OCAMPO, ELISA OCAMPO, BEATRIZ OCAMPO, JUAN
JOHNNY
OCAMPO, JONAS OCAMPO, MARIA DOLORES OCAMPO, REBECCA OCAMPO, FIDELA
OCAMPO,
LUIS OCAMPO JR. AND ERNESTO O. FORTUNO VS. FIDELA LL. OCAMPO,
FELICIDAD
LL. OCAMPO, BELEN OCAMPO-BARRITO, VICENTE BARRITO, NEMESIO LL. OCAMPO,
IMELDA OCAMPO AND JOSE OCAMPO
G.R.
No. 150707 [April 14, 2004]
- ELENA
R. ALCARAZ VS. JUDGE FRANCISCO S. LINDO, METROPOLITAN TRIAL
COURT
OF MALABON, BRANCH 55
A.M.
No. MTJ-04-1539 [April 14, 2004]
- PHILIPPINE
RABBIT BUS LINES, INC. VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES
G.R.
No. 147703 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. RODOLFO RAMOS Y ENRIQUEZ
G.R.
No. 125898 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. CONRADO AYUMAN
G.R.
No. 133436 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. DAVID S. ODILAO, JR.
G.R.
No. 155451 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. LITA AYANGAO Y BATONG-OG
G.R.
No. 142356 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. MARIO ODEN
G.R.
No. 155511-22 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. RICKY QUIMZON
G.R.
No. 133541 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. GATUDAN BALAG-EY AND EDWIN ALIONG Y
SUNGOT
G.R.
No. 141532 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. FLORENCIO CALICA
G.R.
No. 139178 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. MARIO MARCELO Y DELA CRUZ
G.R.
No. 140385 [April 14, 2004]
.- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. JUAN ALCANTARA AND ONE ALIAS AYING
G.R.
No. 157669 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. ANGELITO AMBROSIO Y CAMPOS, ROMAN OZAETA
Y LAO AND WARREN QUE ALIAS WEDDY, WILLY, SHAO WEI GUO, QUE SIAO UY
G.R.
No. 135378 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. ALVIN CAPARAS
G.R.
No. 134633 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. CASIANO BUNTAG, ALIAS “CIANO” AND DIEGO
BONGO
G.R.
No. 123070 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. FRANCISCO DACILLO ALIAS DODOY AND
JOSELITO
PACOT Y IBARRA (CASE PROVISIONALLY DISMISSED)
G.R.
No. 149368 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. NARCISO RAMOS Y MATIAS, RAMON SAN ROQUE
Y
DELA CRUZ, EULALIA SAN ROQUE DE FRANCISCO Y DELA CRUZ ALIAS "LALING,"
WILLIAM
RAMOS ALIAS "WILFREDO RAMOS," (PROVISIONALLY DISMISSED), AND THREE (3)
OTHER JOHN DOES
G.R.
No. 135204 [April 14, 2004]
- LAGRIMAS
A. BOY VS. COURT OF APPEALS, ISAGANI P. RAMOS AND ERLINDA
GASINGAN
RAMOS
G.R.
No. 125088 [April 14, 2004]
- FLORITA
TEOPE VS. THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES AND THE COURT OF APPEALS
G.R.
No. 149687 [April 14, 2004]
- RESTITUTA
M. IMPERIAL VS. ALEX A. JAUCIAN
G.R.
No. 149004 [April 14, 2004]
- EMCO
PLYWOOD CORPORATION AND JIMMY LIM VS. PERFERIO ABELGAS, ARTURO
ABELLANA,
FLORENCIO ABEQUIBEL, FELIZARDO AGUELO, NECERATO ALCALA, PEDRO ALIVIO
JR.,
RODOLFO ALDAYA, ABELARDO AMANTE, NELSON ANGAC, ALEJO ANTOLIJAO, JOHN
ALEX
ARABEJO, REYNALDO ARBOLONIO, RODRIGO ARSILUM, RONALDO BABAYLAN,
LEOPOLDO
BAGA, AGRIPINO BARON, FELIPE BAHIAN, JOEL BADILLA, NARCISO BANTILLAN,
FELIPE
BANDIBAS, ERNESTO BEDRA, ROGELIO BONGATO, ADOLFO BUCAL, DOMINADOR
BUSTILLO,
PLUTARCO CABREROS, FELIPE CAMBARIHAN, PABLO CASANIA, PERFECTO CASTANES,
FERDINAND CASTILLO, ISIDRO CERRO, MARCEDINO CELOCIA, LEODEGARIO CLARO,
ALFREDO CLAVANO, EDILBRETO CUABO, EDILBERTO CURILAN, ANGELA DATIG,
EDDIE
DE LA CRUZ, DOMINO DELA CRUZ, SEGUNDO DELIGERO, RAYMUNDO DESAMPARADO,
GAUDISIO
DEVEYRA, HENRY ENERIO, ANTONIO ENCISO, ANSELMO FELIAS JR., JULIAN
GANZAN,
ALLAN HONCULADA, BIENVENIDO IBALANG, FREDERICK JANOPOL, SAMUEL JUMAMOY,
ISABELO LOREN, PROCORIO LOLOR, RESTITUTO LOMOCSO, PEDRO LOZADA, PEDRO
LOZAGA,
PASTOR MAGARO, ALLAN MANAGA, SIMPLICIO MANDAS, SATURNINO MANISAN,
DIOSDADO
MATA, EMMANUEL MATUTOD, MAXIMO MEDALLE, MARCELINO MINOZA, NORBERTO
MORDEN,
ARNOLD MORDEN, WILLIAM MORADA, RAYMUNDO MORAGAS, RODRIGO MOSQUIDA,
BENITO
NEMENO JR., RICO OGCANG, EMELIANO ONDAP, FRANCISCO PANDAWATAN, ALFREDO
PAIGAN, VENANCIO PAJO, ELY QUINONES, ALEJANDRO QUIPET, BENIGNO
REPOLIDO,
PABLO SUMIDO, JOSE SUMALINOG, SAMUEL TABLA, OSCAR TABANAO, MARIO TELIN,
MANOLITO TIMTIM, FELIX TINDUGAN, DANILO VELUESTO, ALEJANDRO VILVESTRE,
TEOFILO ZAPANTA, RODULFO ALCALA, PERCY ALIPIN, ANGELO AMADA, PAQUITO
ANCAJAS,
EDGARD ARBISO, PERFECTO ARABACA, JUDITH BALMORIA, JOHANNES BONGATO,
NARCISO
BULLECER JR., BERNADITA BURDEOS, WENCESLAO BUSA, RODRIGO CABAL, DONALD
CADILINA, JOSE CAINGHOG, RODOLFO CATUBIG, GADIOSO CASTRODES, VIRGINIA
CERRO,
FORTUNATO CELETONA, JUAN CELLO, MARCIANO CORTEZ, ROLANDO CUMBA, ALMAR
DAPAR,
MARISA DELA CRUZ, SIMEON DELIGERO, DIOSDADO DOMINISE, FLORENTINO
DUNCANO,
CLAUDIO DUMO, MARIDEL EFREN, ROMUALDO ESTRETO, JAIME FLORES, ESMERALDO
GALOPE, PROCESSO HERNANDO, ALFREDO JAVIER, CRISPINO JUGARAP, DANIEL
LABRICA,
ERNESTO LABADAN, AURELIO LINOGAO, BENALDO LOPEZ, AMADOR LUMONGSOD,
FRESCO
LUNOY, FLORENCIO MAGLASANG, EUTIQUEO MAJAIT, ALBINO MANLA, FELIPE
MANTILLA,
CASIANO MELICOR, ANECITA MENDOZA, NEMERIANO NACA, ZACARIAS NALAM, SIXTO
NAPAL JR., ALMAQUIO OBEDENCIO, GODOFREDO OLAIZ, VIRGILIA OSORIO,
ELEUTRIO
PAGADOR, ARDEN PASILANG, DIONESIO PASILANG, ADELAIDO PAQUIPOT, FERNANDO
PATINDOL, VIRGILIO PENDICA, FRANKLIN PILOTON, GIL PILOTON, CHARLITA
PLAZA,
EUFRACIA PLAZA, TORIBEO PUSA, FRANCISCO RAMIRA, BELEN ROJAS, ALFONSO
SABANDAL,
CARMEN SABELLANO, ROGELIO SIMPRON, CENIA SUMILE, ESPEREDION TABIQUE,
ARECIO
TAGHOY, SILVANA TAPALES, JEMCIE TIMTIM, ELENO TORILLO, THOMAS
TERRECAMPO,
FE VALENZUELA, FLORENCIO ABEQUIBEL, EFREN LUMINARIO, AND JULITO ONDAP
G.R.
No. 148532 [April 14, 2004]
- PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. NARCISO SALDAÑA (AT LARGE), ELMER
ESGUERRA (AT LARGE), FERNANDO MORALES, AND ARTURO MALIT
G.R.
No. 148518 [April 15, 2004]
- SPOUSES
JIMMY AND PATRI CHAN VS. REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF ZAMBOANGA DEL
NORTE
IN DIPOLOG CITY, BRANCH 9, CYREANO HAMOY AND SHIELDA HAMOY-SINGALIVO
G.R.
No. 149253 [April 15, 2004]
- PHIL.
EMPLOY SERVICES AND RESOURCES, INC. VS. JOSEPH PARAMIO, RONALD
NAVARRA,
ROMEL SARMIENTO, RECTO GUILLERMO, FERDINAND BAUTISTA AND APOLINARIO
CURAMENG,
JR.
G.R.
No. 144786 [April 15, 2004]
- ROSALIE
ODERON VDA. DE CARDONA VS. MARCELINO AMANSEC
G.R.
No. 147216 [April 15, 2004]
- FRANCISCO
CULABA AND DEMETRIA CULABA, DOING BUSINESS UNDER THE NAME AND STYLE
"CULABA
STORE" VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION
G.R.
No. 125862 [April 15, 2004]
- OFFICE
OF THE COURT ADMINISTRATOR VS. ATTY. EDGAR ALLAN C.
MORANTE,
CLERK OF COURT, R
|
