SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

google search for chanrobles.comSearch for www.chanrobles.com

Endnotes:


1 Rollo, pp. 18-24.

2 Penned by Judge Emmanuel R. Real.

3 Presided by Judge Aurora Binamira-Parcia.

4 Records, p. 1.

5 Records, pp. 18-19.

6 Rollo, p. 6; records, p. 20.

7 Order dated May 23, 1995, issued by the RTC, and Certificate of Arraignment; records, pp. 32-33.

8 Decision, p. 7; Rollo, p. 24.

9 The case was deemed submitted for decision on August 12, 1998, when the Appellees Brief was received by this Court. The filing of a reply brief was deemed waived, as none was submitted within the reglementary period.

10 The Appellees Brief was signed by Solicitor General Ricardo P. Galvez, Assistant Solicitor General Magdangal M. De Leon and Solicitor Bernardo G. Hernandez.

11 Brief for Appellee, pp. 2-4; Rollo, pp. 72-74.

12 The six-page Appellants Brief was signed by Atty. Ingersoll T. Ramirez.

13 Appellants Brief, p. 3; Rollo, p. 38.

14 Appellants Brief, pp. 1 and 4; Rollo, pp. 35 and 39.

15 People v. Barredo, GR No. 122850, October 7, 1998; People v. Gaddi, 170 SCRA 649, February 27, 1989; People v. Pascual, 204 SCRA 618, December 5, 1991; People v. Naparan, 225 SCRA 714, August 30, 1993; People v. Deopante, 263 SCRA 691, October 30, 1996; and People v. Escandor, 265 SCRA 444, December 9, 1996.

16 People v. Rosare, 264 SCRA 398, 410-411, November 19, 1996; People v. Excija, 258 SCRA 424, 439-440, July 5, 1996; People v. Gecomo, 254 SCRA 82, 96, February 23, 1996; People v. Umali, 242 SCRA 17, 22, March 1, 1995; and People v. Nuestro, 240 SCRA 221, 232, January 18, 1995.

17 TSN, July 3, 1995, pp. 5-10.

18 People v. Abrecinoz, 281 SCRA 59, 72, October 17, 1997; People v. Romua, 272 SCRA 818, 828, May 29, 1997; People v. De la Torre, 272 SCRA 615, 624, May 27, 1997; People v. Igdanes, 272 SCRA 113, 123, May 5, 1997; People v. Malabago, 271 SCRA 464, 476, April 18, 1997; and People v. Ligotan, 262 SCRA 602, 610, September 30, 1996.

19 People v. Mamalayan, 280 SCRA 748, 760, October 16, 1997 and People v. Cristobal, 252 SCRA 507, 516, January 29, 1996. See also People v. Gomez, 279 SCRA 688, 696, September 29, 1997; People v. Adora, 275 SCRA 441, 460, July 14, 1997; and People v. De Guzman, 265 SCRA 228, 242, December 2, 1996.

20 People v. Barrera, 262 SCRA 63, 77-78, September 19, 1996; People v. Gabris, 258 SCRA 663, 674, July 11, 1996; People v. Dones, 254 SCRA 696, 708, March 13, 1996; and People v. Caada, 253 SCRA 277, 284, February 6, 1996.

21 People v. Caballes, 274 SCRA 83, 95, June 19, 1997; People v. Andan, 269 SCRA 95, 119, March 3, 1997; and People v. Masagana, 259 SCRA 380, 401, July 26, 1996.

22 TSN, July 3, 1995, pp. 25-26.

23 People v. Adora, 275 SCRA 441, July 14, 1997; People v. De Guzman, 265 SCRA 228, December 2, 1996; People v. Travero, 276 SCRA 301, July 28, 1997; People v. Edualino, 271 SCRA 189, April 11, 1997.

24 People v. Caada, 253 SCRA 277, 285 February 6, 1996; People v. Antonio, 233 SCRA 299, June 17, 1994; People v. Matrimonio, 215 SCRA 613, November 13, 1992; People v. Grefiel, 215 SCRA 506, November 13, 1992; People v. Pamor, 237 SCRA 472, October 7, 1994.

25 People v. Rabosa, 273 SCRA 142, 150, June 9, 1997; People v. Igdanes, 272 SCRA 113, 120, May 5, 1997; and People v. Corea, 269 SCRA 76, 92, March 3, 1997.

26 People v. Pareja, 265 SCRA 429, 440, December 9, 1996; People v. Balamban, 264 SCRA 619, 631, November 21, 1996; People v. Layno, 264 SCRA 558, 574, November 21, 1996; People v. Magana, 259 SCRA 380, 391, July 26, 1996; People v. Ocsimar, 253 SCRA 689, 695, February 20, 1996; People v. Danao, 253 SCRA 146, 153, February 1, 1996; People v. Lapuz, 250 SCRA 250, 255, November 23, 1995.

27 People v. Villaruel, 261 SCRA 386, 396, September 4, 1996; People v. Tazo, 260 SCRA 816, 820, August 22, 1996; People v. Ramos, 260 SCRA 402, 410, August 7, 1996; People v. Caguioa Sr., 259 SCRA 403, 408, July 26, 1996; People v. Bracamonte, 257 SCRA 380, 392, June 17, 1996; People v. Porras, 255 SCRA 514, 526, March 29, 1996; and People v. Caada, 253 SCRA 277, 286, February 6, 1996.

28 TSN, July 25, 1995, p. 5.

29 TSN, July 3, 1995, pp. 21-22.

30 TSN, July 6, 1995, pp. 3-13.

31 TSN, July 7, 1995, pp. 3-33.

32 People v. Panlilio, 255 SCRA 503, 512, March 29, 1996; People v. Ferrer, 255 SCRA 19, 35, March 14, 1996; People v. Banal, 254 SCRA 659, 670, March 13, 1996; People v. Trilles, 254 SCRA 633, 642, March 12, 1996; People v. Juan, 254 SCRA 478, 489, March 7, 1996; People v. Patrolla Jr., 254 SCRA 467, 475, March 7, 1996; People v. Mendoza, 254, SCRA 61, 75, February 23, 1996; People v. Abrenica, 252 SCRA 54, 62, January 18, 1996.

33 People v. Bernaldez, GR No. 109780, August 17, 1998; People v. Betonio, 279 SCRA 525, 552, September 26, 1997; People v. Adora, 275 SCRA 441, 470, July 14, 1997; People v. Caballes, 274 SCRA 83, 100, June 19, 1997; and People v. Dones, 254 SCRA 696, 710, March 13, 1996.




chanrobles.com



ChanRobles Professional Review, Inc.

ChanRobles Professional Review, Inc. : www.chanroblesprofessionalreview.com
ChanRobles On-Line Bar Review

ChanRobles Internet Bar Review : www.chanroblesbar.com
ChanRobles CPA Review Online

ChanRobles CPALE Review Online : www.chanroblescpareviewonline.com
ChanRobles Special Lecture Series

ChanRobles Special Lecture Series - Memory Man : www.chanroblesbar.com/memoryman