ChanRobles Virtual law Library




SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

google search for chanrobles.comSearch for www.chanrobles.com

PLEASE CLICK HERE FOR THE LATEST ➔ SUPREME COURT DECISIONS







April 2005 - PHILIPPINE SUPREME COURT DECISIONS



A.M. No. MTJ-02-1452 : April 6, 2005
Editha O. Catbagan vs. Judge Felixberto P. Barte

Resolution

J . Corona


A.M. No. P-05-1974 : April 6, 2005
Rodolfo T. Baquerfo vs. Gerry C. Sanchez

Decision

Per Curiam


A.M. No. P-05-1981 : April 6, 2005
Civil Service Commission vs. Emma S. Javier

Decision

Per Curiam


A.M. No. RTJ-05-1909 : April 6, 2005
Community Rural Bank of Guimba, Inc. vs. Judge Tomas B. Talavera.


G.R. No. 134155 : April 6, 2005
Angelito Uy vs. Pableo S. Baloja

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 147812 : April 6, 2005
Leonardo R. Ocampo vs. Leonora Tirona

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 150129 : April 6, 2005
Norma A. Abdulla vs. People of the Philippines.


G.R. No. 162270 : April 6, 2005
Abacus Real Estate Development Center, Inc. vs. The Manila Banking Corporation

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 136062 : April 7, 2005
Trifilo Montebon vs. Atty. Corazon Tanglao-Dacanay, Et Al

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 151922 : April 7, 2005
Amelita M. Escareal, Et Al. vs. Philippines Airlines, Inc., Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 140777 : April 8, 2005
Antonio Abacan, Jr., Et Al. vs. Northwestern University, Inc

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 152039 : April 8, 2005
F.F. Marine Corporation, Et Al. vs. The Honorable Second Division National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 161135 : April 8, 2005
Swagman Hotels and Travel, Inc. vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

C.J. Davide, Jr.


A.M. No. P-05-1934 : April 11, 2005
Jose and Milagros Villaceran vs. Wilmer M. Beltejar

Decision

J . Puno


G.R. No. 139018 : April 11, 2005
Estherlita Cruz-Agana vs. Hon. Judge Aurora Santiago-Lagman, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 150897 : April 11, 2005
Turadio C. Domingo vs. Jose C. Domingo, Et Al

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 143380 : April 11, 2005
Olimpio Pangonorom, Et Al. vs. People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 150915 : April 11, 2005
Mario Manaban, Et Al. vs. Sarphil Corporation, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 157781 : April 11, 2005
Robert Crisanto D. Lee vs. People of the Philippines, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 164857 : April 11, 2005
Flexo Marketing Corporation vs. Columbus Foods, Incorporated, Et Al

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.C. No. 5637 : April 12, 2005
Cristina A. Arienda vs. Atty. Porfirio Aguila

Resolution

J . Chico-Nazario


A.M. No. CA-05-18-P : April 12, 2005
Zaldy Nuez vs. Elvira Cruz-Apao

Decision

Per Curiam


G.R. No. 118127 : April 12, 2005
City of Manila, Et Al. vs. Hon. Perfecto A.S. Laguio, Jr., Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 129472 : April 12, 2005
Marcelo Lasoy, Et Al. vs. Hon. Monina A. Zenarosa, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 134509 : April 12, 2005
Venancio R. Nava vs. National Bureau of Investigation

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 139325 : April 12, 2005
Priscilla C. Mijares, Et Al. vs. Hon. Santiago Javier Ranada, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 140182 : April 12, 2005
Tanay Recreation Center And Development Corp. vs. Catalina Matienzo Fausto, Et Al

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 140954 : April 12, 2005
Heirs of Bertuldo Hinog vs. Hon. Achilles Melicor, Et Al

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 144095 : April 12, 2005
Spouses Haymaton S. Garingan, Et Al. vs. Hadji Munib Saupi Garingan, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 149765 : April 12, 2005
Arturo Mejia vs. Filomena Gabayan, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 151809-12 : April 12, 2005
Presidential Commission on Good Government (PCGG) vs. Sandiganbayan, Et Al

Decision

J . Puno

Concurring Opinion

J. Sandoval-Gutierrez

Dissenting Opinion

J. Carpio-Morales

J. Callejo, Sr.

Separate Opinion

J. Panganiban

J. Tinga


G.R. No. 155009 : April 12, 2005
Simeon M. Valdez vs. China Banking Corporation

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 156047 : April 12, 2005
Engr. Pedro C. Rubio, Jr. vs. Hon. Emmanuel M. Paras

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 158138 : April 12, 2005
Philippine Bank of Communications vs. Elena Lim, Et Al

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 162733 : April 12, 2005
Erasmo Tayao vs. Rosa D. Mendoza, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 165751 : April 12, 2005
Datu Guimid P. Matalam vs. The Second Division of the Sandiganbayan, Et Al

Resolution

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 144486 : April 13, 2005
Radio Communications of the Philippines, Inc. vs. Provincial Assessor of South Cotabato, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 148830 : April 13, 2005
National Housing Authority vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio


G.R. No. 149371 : April 13, 2005
Aberdeen Court, Inc., Et Al. vs. Mateo C. Agustin, Jr

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 152398 : April 14, 2005
Edgar Crisostomo vs. Sandiganbayan

Decision

J . Carpio


A.C. No. 5835 : April 15, 2005
Carlos B. Reyes vs. Atty. Jeremias R. Vitan

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


A.C. No. 5864 : April 15, 2005
Arturo L. Sicat vs. Atty. Gregorio E. Ariola, Jr

Resolution

Per Curiam


A.C. No. 6595 : April 15, 2005
Joseph Samala vs. Atty. Antonuitti K. Palaa

Resolution

J . Azcuna


A.M. No. MTJ-04-1547 : April 15, 2005
Josefina C. Ribaya vs. Judge Aurora Binamira-Parcia

Resolution

J . Corona


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1587 : April 15, 2005
Pilar Barredo-Fuentes, Et Al. vs. Judge Romeo C. Albarracin

Resolution

J . Tinga


A.M. No. P-04-1927 : April 15, 2005
Alicia Aradanas vs. Catherine V. Dimaclid, Et Al

Resolution

J . Quisumbing


A.M. No. P-05-1986 : April 15, 2005
Atty. Generoso Legaspi, Jr. vs. Atty. J. Rogelio T. Montero III

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. RTJ-05-1910 : April 15, 2005
Alfredo Hilado, Et Al. vs. Judge Amor A. Reyes

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 122904 : April 15, 2005
Adoracion E. Cruz, Et Al. vs.The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 130230 : April 15, 2005
Metropolitan Manila Development Authority vs. Dante O. Garin

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 133638 : April 15, 2005
Perpetua Vda. De Ape vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 140495 : April 15, 2005
G & M (Phils.), Inc. vs. Epifanio Cruz

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 142286-87 : April 15, 2005
Korea Exchange Bank vs. Hon. Rogelio C. Gonzales, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 142944 : April 15, 2005
Edenbert Madrigal, Et Al. vs. The Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 142960 : April 15, 2005
Manila Pearl Corporation vs. Manila Pearl Independent Workers Union

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 147002 : April 15, 2005
Philippine Telegraph & Telephone Corporation, Et Al. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 149793 : April 15, 2005
Wack Wack Golf & Country Club vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 150478 : April 15, 2005
Hacienda Bino/Hortencia Starke, Inc., Et Al. vs. Candido Cuenca, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 151303 : April 15, 2005
Athenna International Manpower Services, Inc. vs. Nonito Villanos

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 152481 : April 15, 2005
Ramon Pablo y Bacungan vs. People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Quisumbing


G.R. No. 153573-76. April 15, 2005

People of the Philippines vs. Wilson Suarez y Villones, Et Al

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago

Dissenting Opinion

J. Quisumbing


G.R. No. 153777 : April 15, 2005
Planters Development Bank vs. LZK Holdings and Development Corporation

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 154368 : April 15, 2005
Danzas Intercontinental, Inc., Et Al. vs. Henry M. Daguman, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 155181 : April 15, 2005
Liberty Ayo-Alburo vs. Uldarico Matobato

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 159647 : April 15, 2005
Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Central Luzon Drug Corporation.


G.R. No. 161065 : April 15, 2005
Eufemio C. Domingo, Et Al. vs. Hon. Guillermo N. Carague, Et Al

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 163123 : April 15, 2005
Philippine Health Insurance Corporation vs. Chinese General Hospital and Medical Center

Decision

J . Corona


A.C. No. 6585 : April 21, 2005
Tomas B. Yumol, Jr., Et Al. vs. Atty. Roberto R. Ferrer, Sr

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 142030 : April 21, 2005
Arturo Gallardo, Et Al. vs. People of the Philippines, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


A.C. No. 5655 : April 22, 2005
Valeriano U. Dalisay vs. Atty. Melanio Mauricio, Jr

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


A.M. No. P-04-1866 : April 22, 2005
Office of the Court Administrator vs. Evacuato F. Balbona

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 101487 : April 22, 2005
Raul H. Sesbreo vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Garcia


G.R. No. 146006 : April 22, 2005
Jose C. Lee, Et Al. vs. Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 85, Et Al

Resolution

J . Corona


G.R. No. 150255 : April 22, 2005
Schmitz Transport & Brokerage Corporation vs. Transport Venture, Inc., Et Al

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 156171 : April 22, 2005
Spouses Ricardo and Ferma Portic vs. Anastacia Cristobal

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 157195 : April 22, 2005
Vicar International Construction, Inc., Et Al. vs. FEB Leasing and Finance Corporation

Decision

J . Panganiban


A.M. No. 05-2-101-RTC : April 26, 2005
Report on theJudicial Audit Conducted in the Regional Trial Court, Branch 8, Cebu City

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


A.M. No. MTJ-05-1589 : April 26, 2005
Zenaida J. Castro vs. Judge Nicasio V. Bartolome

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. P-05-1993 : April 26, 2005
Vice-Executive Judge Divina Luz P. Aquino-Simbulan vs. Edgardo A. Zabat

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 109976 : April 26, 2005
Philippine National Oil Company vs. The Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario

Dissenting Opinion

J. Carpio

Separate Opinion

J. Tinga


G.R. No. 128354 : April 26, 2005
Home Bankers Savings & Trust Co. vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 140301 : April 26, 2005
Paul C. Del Moral, Et Al. vs. Republic of the Philippines, Et Al

Decision

J . Austria-Martinez


G.R. No. 145441 : April 26, 2005
Philippine Savings Bank vs. Sps. Rodolfo C. Maalac, Jr., Et Al

Decision

J . Ynares-Santiago


G.R. No. 146997 : April 26, 2005
Spouses Godofredo & Dominica Flancia vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Corona


G.R. No. 147080 : April 26, 2005
Capitol Medical Center, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 156317 : April 26, 2005
Carlos F. Salomon, Et Al. vs. Associate of International Shipping Lines, Inc

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 156447 : April 26, 2005
Juan Agas, Et Al. vs. Caridad Sabico

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 157718 : April 26, 2005

Alvin Amployo y Ebalada vs. People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 161784-86 : April 26, 2005
Dinah C. Barriga vs. The Honorable Sandiganbayan (4th Division), Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 161904 : April 26, 2005
Asian Construction and Development Corporation vs. Noel T. Tulabut

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.C. No. 1109 : April 27, 2005
Maria Elena Moreno vs. Atty. Ernesto Araneta

Decision

Per Curiam


A.C. No. 5365 : April 27, 2005
Spouses Franklin and Lourdes Olbes vs. Atty. Victor V. Deciembre

Decision

J . Panganiban


A.M. No. 02-9-233-MTCC : April 27, 2005
In Re: Report on the Judicial and Financial Audit Conducted in the Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Koronadal City

Decision

J . Panganiban


A.M. No. MTJ-00-1313 : April 27, 2005
Virgilio P. Alconera vs. Judge Jose S. Majaducon

Resolution

J . Corona


A.M. No. P-98-1281 : April 27, 2005
Office of the Court Administrator vs. Sylvia R. Yan

Decision

Per Curiam


G.R. No. 155108 : April 27, 2005
Republic of the Philippines, Et Al. vs. Emiliano R. Nolasco

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 157684 : April 27, 2005
Department of Health vs. Priscilla G. Camposano, Et Al

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 133709 : April 28, 2005
Constante Siccuan vs. People of the Philippines

Decision

J . Sandoval-Gutierrez


G.R. No. 149252 : April 28, 2005
Donald Kwok vs. Philippine Carpet Manufacturing Corporation

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 151857 : April 28, 2005
Calamba Steel Center, Inc. vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Decision

J . Panganiban


G.R. No. 159922 : April 28, 2005
Armando F. Chan vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


A.M. No. P-03-1755 : April 29, 2005
Judge Manuel S. Sollesta vs. Salvacion B. Mission

Decision

Per Curiam


A.M. No. RTJ-05-1896 : April 29, 2005
Atty. Julius Neri vs. Judge Jesus S. De la Pea

Resolution

J . Corona


G.R. No. 128392 : April 29, 2005
Cesar Mateo, Et Al. vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Azcuna


G.R. No. 132209 : April 29, 2005
Carlos C. Buendia vs. City of Iligan

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 147632 : April 29, 2005
Rey Geal vs. Emma Geal

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 148323 : April 29, 2005
Bernardino S. Manioso vs. Government Service Insurance System

Decision

J . Carpio-Morales


G.R. No. 148470 : April 29, 2005
Lopez Dela Rosa Development Corporation, Et Al. vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 150736 : April 29, 2005
Virgilio Macaspac vs. Ruperto Puyat, Jr

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 151827 : April 29, 2005
Josefina Benares vs. Jaime Pancho, Et Al

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 152324 : April 29, 2005
Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Hon. Pepito Planta, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 155037 : April 29, 2005
Anvil Ensemles Garment vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 155059 : April 29, 2005
American Wire & Cable Daily Rated Employees Union vs. American Wire And Cable Co., Inc., Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 155207 : April 29, 2005
Wilhelmina S. Orozco vs. The Fifth Division of the Honorable Court of Appeals, Et Al

Resolution

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 155478 : April 29, 2005
Spouses Guillermo and Andylynn Hizo vs. Court of Appeals, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 157146 : April 29, 2005
Laguna Autoparts Manufacturing Corporation vs. Office of the Secretary, Department of Labor and Employment, Et Al

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.


G.R. No. 157447 : April 29, 2005
Nemencio C. Evangelista, Et Al. vs. Carmelino M. Santiago

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 158758 : April 29, 2005
P.J. Lhuillier Inc., Et Al. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et Al

Decision

J . Chico-Nazario


G.R. No. 159145 : April 29, 2005
Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board, Et Al. vs. Josefina S. Lubrica, Et Al.

Decision

J . Tinga


G.R. No. 160384 : April 29, 2005
Cesar T. Hilario vs. Alan T. Salvador

Decision

J . Callejo, Sr.



























chanrobles.com