US SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

OULD V. WASHINGTON HOSPITAL FOR FOUNDLINGS, 95 U. S. 303 (1877)

Subscribe to Cases that cite 95 U. S. 303

U.S. Supreme Court

Ould v. Washington Hospital for Foundlings, 95 U.S. 303 (1877)

Ould v. Washington Hospital for Foundlings

95 U.S. 303

Syllabus

1. A., by his last will and testament, admitted to probate June 22, 1864, devised certain lots of ground in the District of Columbia to two trustees,

"and the survivor of them, and the heirs, executors, administrators, and assigns of such survivor, in trust, nevertheless, and to and for and upon the uses, intents, and purposes following, that is to say, in trust to hold the said lots of ground, with the appurtenances as and for a site for the erection of a hospital for foundlings, to be built and erected by and association, society, or institution that may hereafter be incorporated by an act of Congress as and for such hospital, and upon such incorporation, upon further trust to grant and convey the said lots of ground and trust estate to the corporation or institution so incorporated for said purpose of the erection of a hospital, which conveyance shall be absolute and in fee, provided nevertheless that such corporation shall be approved by my said trustees, or the survivor of them or their successors in the trust, and if not so approved, then upon further trust to hold the said lots and trust estate for the same purpose until a corporation shall be so created by act of Congress which shall meet the approval of the said trustees or the survivor or successors of them, to whom full discretion is given in this behalf, and upon such approval in trust to convey as aforesaid, and I recommend to my said trustees to select an institution which shall not be under the control of any one religious sect or persuasion, and until such conveyance I direct the taxes, charges, and assessments, and all necessary expenses of, for, and upon said lots, and every

Page 95 U. S. 304

one of them, to he paid by my executors as they shall from time to time accrue and become due and payable, out of the residue of my estate."

The Washington Hospital for Foundlings was incorporated by an Act of Congress approved April 22, 1870, 16 Stat. 92, and, on the 4th of April, 1872, the trustees under the will conveyed said lots to that corporation in fee. Held: 1. that the devise is not invalid for uncertainty, or because it creates a perpetuity; 2. that the provision touching a conveyance by the trustees whenever Congress should create a corporation for foundlings which they approved was only a conditional limitation of the estate vested in them; 3. that the duty with which they were charged was an executory trust, and their conveyance was necessary to and did pass the title.

2. The statute of 43 Eliz., c. 4, was purely remedial and ancillary. It was never in force in the District of Columbia, and the validity of charitable endowments, and the jurisdiction of courts of equity over them, does not depend upon it.

3. The doctrine of charitable uses and trusts discussed, and the authorities bearing upon it cited and approved.

This is an action of ejectment by the plaintiffs in error, who were plaintiffs below, to recover fourteen lots of ground, being part of square numbered two hundred and seven in the City of Washington. The defendant pleaded not guilty. The case was tried upon the following agreed statement of facts:

The defendant, the Washington Hospital for Foundlings, admits:

First, that Joshua Peirce, late of the District of Columbia, died on the eleventh day of April, 1869.

Second, that he died seised of the real estate set forth and described in the plaintiffs' declaration.

Third, that the plaintiffs, Elizabeth C. Ould, Elizabeth C. Beardsley, Samuel Simonton, Abnor P. Simonton, David S. Simonton, John E. Simonton, Hannah P. Jackson, Eliza F. Tibbetts, Abner C. P. Shoemaker, and Peirce Shoemaker, are the heirs-at-law, and the only heirs-at-law, of said Peirce.

The plaintiffs admit:

First, that said Peirce, on the fifteenth day of October, 1867, duly executed his last will and testament, commencing as follows:

"I, Joshua Peirce, of the County of Washington, in the District of Columbia, do make this my last will and testament in manner and form following. "

Page 95 U. S. 305

That following this is a revocation of other wills, then a provision for the payment of debts, then several specific devises, and then the fourteenth item, in the following words:

"Fourteenth, I give, devise, and bequeath all those fourteen certain lots or pieces of ground, part of square numbered two hundred and seven, situate between R and S Streets North and Fourteenth and Fifteenth Streets West, in the said City of Washington, in the District of Columbia, which lots are numbered from number twenty-four to number thirty-seven, inclusive, on a certain plan of subdivision of the said square, registered and recorded in the surveyor's office for the said city, in liber W F, folio 211, and are situate on the east side of the said Fifteenth Street, at the distance of one hundred and sixty feet northward from the north side of the said R Street north, containing together in front on the said Fifteenth Street west one hundred and thirty feet, and in depth eastward between parallel lines two hundred and ninety-four feet and a half inch, more or less, to Johnson Avenue (including in the said depth a twenty-feet-wide alley, laid out through the middle of the said lots), to my friends, William M. Shuster and William H. Clagett, both of the said City of Washington, and the survivor of them, an the heirs, executors, administrators, and assigns of such survivor, in trust, nevertheless, and to, for, and upon the uses, intents, and purposes following, that is to say, in trust to hold the said fourteen lots of ground with the appurtenances as and for a site for the erection of a hospital for foundlings, to be built and erected by any association, society, or institution that may hereafter be incorporated by an act of Congress as and for such hospital, and upon such incorporation upon further trust to grant and convey the said lots of ground and trust estate to the corporation or institution so incorporated for the said purpose of the erection of a hospital, which conveyance shall be absolute and in fee, provided, nevertheless, that such corporation shall be approved by my said trustees, or the survivor of them, or their successors in the trust, and if not so approved, then upon further trust to hold the said lots and trust estate for the same purpose until a corporation shall be so created by act of Congress, which shall meet the approval of the said trustees, or the survivor or successors of them, to whom full discretion is given in this behalf, and upon such approval in trust to convey as aforesaid, and I recommend to my said trustees to select an institution which shall not be under the control of any one religious sect or persuasion; and until such conveyance, I direct the taxes, charges, and assessments,

Page 95 U. S. 306

and all necessary expenses of, for, and upon the said lots, and every one of them, to be paid by my executors, as they shall from time to time accrue and become due and payable, out of the residue of my estate."

That following this is a devise of the "rest, residue, and remainder" of the testator's estate, "real and personal, including his estate called Linnaean Hill," in trust to trustees for the use of the testator's wife's nephew in tail with a devise over.

Second, that on the twenty-second day of June, 1869, the said will was duly proved and admitted to probate in the Orphans' Court of the District of Columbia.

Third, that on the twenty-second day of April, 1870, Congress passed an "Act for incorporating a hospital for foundlings in the City of Washington," 16 Stat. 92, and that on the fourth day of April, 1872, said Shuster and Clagett, trustees, conveyed the property described in the declaration and the above fourteenth item of the will to the defendant, so incorporated in conformity with the directions of the testator.

The court below found for the defendant, whereupon the plaintiffs brought the case here. chanrobles.com-red

Page 95 U. S. 307



























chanrobles.com



ChanRobles Legal Resources:

ChanRobles On-Line Bar Review

ChanRobles Internet Bar Review : www.chanroblesbar.com

ChanRobles MCLE On-line

ChanRobles Lawnet Inc. - ChanRobles MCLE On-line : www.chanroblesmcleonline.com