April 2008 - Philippine Supreme Court Resolutions
Philippine Supreme Court Resolutions
Philippine Supreme Court Resolutions > Year 2008 > April 2008 Resolutions >
[A.M. No. 08-3-73-MeTC : April 22, 2008] RE: REPORT ON THE JUDICIAL AUDIT CONDUCTED AT THE METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT (METC), BRANCH 55, MALABON CITY. :
[A.M. No. 08-3-73-MeTC : April 22, 2008]
RE: REPORT ON THE JUDICIAL AUDIT CONDUCTED AT THE METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT (METC), BRANCH 55, MALABON CITY.
Sirs/Mesdames:
Quoted hereunder, for your information, is a resolution of the Court En Banc dated April 22, 2008
"A.M. No. 08-3-73-MeTC.- Re: Report on the Judicial Audit Conducted at the Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC), Branch 55, Malabon City.- The Court Resolved to NOTE the Memorandum dated March 17, 2008 of Deputy Court Administrator (DCA) Jose P. Perez, submitting the report of the team which conducted the judicial audit in the MeTC, Br. 55, Matabon City.
The Court further Resolved, upon the recommendation of the judicial audit team with recommending approval of DCA Perez, to
"A.M. No. 08-3-73-MeTC.- Re: Report on the Judicial Audit Conducted at the Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC), Branch 55, Malabon City.- The Court Resolved to NOTE the Memorandum dated March 17, 2008 of Deputy Court Administrator (DCA) Jose P. Perez, submitting the report of the team which conducted the judicial audit in the MeTC, Br. 55, Matabon City.
The Court further Resolved, upon the recommendation of the judicial audit team with recommending approval of DCA Perez, to
- DIRECT Hon. Francisco S. Lindo, former Presiding Judge, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 55, Malabon City to EXPLAIN in writing within fifteen (15) days from notice why no administrative sanction shall be imposed on him for1.1failure to report to this Court, through the Office of the Court Administrator, about the following nineteen (19) inherited cases which were allegedly discovered sometime in 2002 or to decide them considering that these cases were submitted for decision way back in the 80's, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. 525-81 & 525-82, 54839, 634-84, 777-84, 909-84, 974-84, 1025-85, 1023-85, 2122-86, 2223-86, 2256-86 & 2249-87; and Civil Case Nos. 529-86, 621-86, 755-87, 767-87, 774-87 & 819-88;1.2failure to decide within the reglementary period the following three (3) cases which were submitted for his decision, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. 360-90 and 361-90; and Civil Case No. 1870-98;1.3failure to resolve within the reglementary period the following seven (7) cases with pending incident or matter for his resolution, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. 7305-98, 7818-98, JLOO-577 & JLOO-578; and.Civil Case Nos. JLOO-258, JLOO-259 & JLOO-272;1.4failure to act on the one thousand two hundred twenty-nine (1,229) criminal cases and twenty-nine (29) civil cases, as enumerated in Annex "A" of the audit report, despite the lapse of a considerable length of time;1.5failure to act on the following twenty-one (21) criminal cases which have not been set in the court calendar despite the lapse of a considerable period of time from date of filing, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. JLOO5822 to JLOO5831, JLOO-5963 to JLOO-5967, JLOO-5934, JLOO-7247, JLOO-7248, JLOO-7571, JLOO-7572, JLOO-7573; and1.6failure to reflect, in all the Monthly Report of Cases he filed with this Office, the nineteen (19) inherited cases submitted for decision as well as Criminal Case Nos. 360-91 and 361-91 submitted for his decision on October 17, 1994 and Civil Case No. 1870-98 submitted for his decision on August 10,1999.
- DIRECT Ms. Edrine T. Borgonia, Court Legal Researcher and Officer-in-Charge, MeTC, Branch 55, Malabon City to1.1EXPLAIN within fifteen (15) days from notice why no administrative sanction shall be imposed upon her for1.1.1failure to set in the court calendar the following twenty-one (21) criminal cases despite the lapse of considerable period of time, with further directive for her to immediately include them in the court calendar, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. JLOO5822 to JLOO5831, JLOO-5963 to JLOO-5967, JLOO-5934, JLOO-7247, JLOO-7248, JLOO-7571, JLOO-7572, JLOO-7573;1.1.2failure to present to the audit team for examination the following one hundred seventy-five (175) criminal cases:
3621-96 JLOO-5214 JLOO-6683 JLOO-9034 6719-97 JLOO-5235 JLOO-6817 JLOO-9046 7354-98 JLOO-5242 JLOO-6818 JLOO-9081 9830-00 JLOO-5249 JLOO-6853 JLOO-9090 9641-00 JLOO-5391 JLOO-6869 JLOO-9091 8242-99 JLOO-5437 JLOO-6939 to JLOO-9094 8457-99 JLOO-5446 JLOO-6946 JLOO-9101 8458-99 JLOO-5461 JLOO-7074 JLOO-9109 8459-99 JLOO-5483 JLOO-7711 JLOO-9119 8460-99 JLOO-5489 JLOO-7882 JLOO-9138 to 8490-99 JLOO-5681 JLOO-7910 JLOO-9140 JIOO-087 JLOO-5777 JLOO-7946 JLOO-9150 JIOO-117 JLOO-6022 JLOO-7947 JLOO-9156 JIOO-758 JLOO-6271 to JLOO-7952 JLOO-9174 JIOO-940 JLOO-6278 JLOO-8094 JLOO-9177 JLOO-947 JLOO-6336 JLOO-8210 JLOO-9211 JLOO-948 JLOO-6337 JLOO-8226 JLOO-9222 JIOO-1079 JLOO-6343 JLOO-8227 JLOO-9238 to JIOO-1517 JLOO-6360 JLOO-8229 JLOO-9241 JIOO-1666 JLOO-6367 JLOO-8237 JLOO-9247 JIOO-2643 JLOO-6378 JLOO-8287 JLOO-9248 JLOO-2779 JLOO-6490 JLOO-8488 JLOO-9414 JIOO-3058 JLOO-6512 JLOO-8558 to JLOO-9467 JIOO-3220 JLOO-6521 JLOO-8584 JLOO-9494 to JIOO-3221 JLOO-6533 JLOO-8776 JLOO-9499 JIOO-3269 JLOO-6564 JLOO-8781 JLOO-9742 JIOO-3564 JLOO-6574 JLOO-8822 JLOO-9755 JLOO-3785 JLOO-6575 JLOO-8862 to JLOO-9770 JIOO-4088 to JLOO-6631 JLOO-8867 JLOO-9938 JIOO-4090 JLOO-6670 JLOO-9001 JIOO-4198 JLOO-6674 JLOO-9028 JLOO-4211 JLOO-6698 JLOO-9030 1.1.3failure to include the following cases in the semestral docket inventory for the years 2006 and 2007:525-81 8199-99 JLOO-2584 to JLOO-9056 to 525-82 8231-99 JLOO-2588 JLOO-9061 54839 8298-99 JLOO-2778 JLOO-9073 634-84 8638-99 JLOO-2825 to JLOO-9095 777-84 8846-99 JLOO-2874 JLOO-5822 to 909-84 9001-99 JLOO-2892 to JLOO-5828 974-84 9002-99 JLOO-2917 JLOO-9146 1023-85 9182-99 JLOO-3109 JLOO-9179 1025-85 9287-99 to JLOO-3241 JLOO-9277 to 2122-86 9295-99 JLOO-3322 JLOO-9280 2223-86 9395-99 JLOO-3446 JLOO-9281 to 2256-86 9579-99 JLOO-3620 JLOO-9304 2249-87 9599-99 JLOO-3621 JLOO-9370 253-90 9600-99 JLOO-3622 JLOO-9536 360-91 9697-00 JLOO-3860 to JLOO-9540 361-91 9739-00 JLOO-3869 JLOO-9580 402-91 9839-00 to JLOO-4328 JLOO-9581 1029-94 9845-00 JLOO-4685 JLOO-9582 1541-94 9986-00 JLOO-5246 JLOO-9605 2584-95 to 10016-00 JLOO-5417 JLOO-9632 2587-95 10273-00 JLOO-5622 JLOO-9709 2661-95 to JLOO-275 JLOO-5749 JLOO-9742 2669-95 JLOO-311 JLOO-5967 JLOO-9886 3998-96 JLOO-767 JLOO-6677 & JLOO-9887 4000-96 JLOO-893 to JLOO-4821 8102 6639-97 JLOO-899 JLOO-7133 8242 6847-97 JLOO-900 to JLOO-7456 8243 6976-98 JLOO-904 JLOO-7562 6934 7203-98 JLOO-1101 JLOO-9014 7305-98 JLOO-1829 JLOO-9015 7426-98 JLOO-2020 JLOO-9016 7818-98 JLOO-2033 1.2SUBMIT within thirty (30) days from notice a written report, duly noted by the Acting Presiding Judge, on the status of the one hundred seventy-five (175) criminal cases enumerated in Item 2.1.2 above;1.3IMPLEMENT a systematic records management; and1.4FILE ON TIME the Monthly Report of Cases and the Semestral Docket Inventory of Cases following strictly the prescribed format therefor. - DIRECT Judge Eduardo T. Pacis, Acting Presiding Judge, MeTC, Branch 55, Malabon City to3.1DECIDE within ninety (90) days from receipt of notice the following nineteen (19) inherited cases of Judge Lindo which were submitted for decision way back in the 80's, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. 525-81 & 525-82, 54839, 634-84, 777-84, 909-84, 974-84, 1025-85, 1023-85, 2122-86, 2223-86, 2256-86 & 2249-87; and Civil Case Nos. 529-86, 621-86, 755-87, 767-87, 774-87 & 819-88;3.2DECIDE within ninety (90) days from receipt of notice the following cases submitted for decision before Judge Lindo but were left undecided, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. 360-90 and 361-90; and Civil Case Nos. 1870-98 and JLOO-830;3.3RESOLVE within ninety (90) days from receipt of notice the pending incidents/motions submitted for resolution in connection with the following cases, to wit: Criminal Case Nos. 7305-98, 7818-98, JLOO-577 & JLOO-578; and Civil Case Nos. JLOO-258, JLOO-259 & JLOO-272; and
3.4ACT with dispatch on the one thousand two hundred twenty-nine (1,229) criminal cases and twenty-nine (29) civil cases, as enumerated in Annex "A" of the audit report, which have no further action for a considerable length of time. - ORDER the Financial Management Office, Office of the Court Administrator to SET ASIDE the sum of One Hundred Thousand Pesos (P100,000.00) from the retirement benefits of Judge Francisco S. Lindo, former Presiding Judge, MeTC, Branch 55, Malabon City to answer for any liability that the Honorable Court may impose on said judge by reason of this audit report.
- ORDER the Financial Management Office, Office of the Court Administrator to RELEASE to Judge Lindo his retirement benefits after deducting therefrom the abovementioned retention amount, subject to the usual clearance requirements." Corona, J., on leave.
Very truly yours,
(Sgd.) MA. LUISA D. VILLARAMA
Clerk of Court
(Sgd.) MA. LUISA D. VILLARAMA
Clerk of Court